Gapital gain applicability- special case- interesting one

730 views 2 replies

We are 2 brothers, one sister & mother, have one ancestral property which our great grand father had purchased in 1932. It was inherited to our grand father who was the only son. Our grand father had distributed this propoerty to his 2 sons in 1995 thru a family settlement by a court in which all the 3 daugters and other family members were the witnesses.It means my father became owner of this property in 1995 legally. My father has expired in 2008 and idealy this property has been inherited to all 4 of us (2 brothers, one sister & mother). Now we are selling this property in 2012-13. The cost of purchase in 1932 was almost negligible. I have the following queries:-

  1. As it is an inherited property, the cost to previous owner should be considered. It means the cost which was in 1932 or the fair market value as on 1st Apr 1981 or in 1995 when my father became a legal owner of this property or 2008 when we became legal owner?
  2. How the indexation will work in this case......from 1981 to 1995 than 1995 to 2008 & than 2008 to 2012 or something else.
  3. If any gain arise on sale of the property, in whose hand the capital gain tax would be applicable from all 4 of us.
  4. If it is taxable in all 4 of us than can we buy new property jointly or individually to save the tax.
  5. Can we save the tax thru a HUF route, if yes, than what should we have to do.

It would be of great help if someone advise on this to us.

Regards,

Nitin Agarwal

+91 9971398485

 

Replies (2)

INDEXATION BENIFIT WILL APPLY FROM DATE OF INHERITANCE BY UR FAMILY(TWO BROTHERS,ONE SISTER AND UR MOTHER) SO INDEXATION BENIFIT WILL APPLY FROM 2008 TO 2012

BUT IF THIS PROPERTY LEGAL OWNER IS HUF,ON PARTITION IF UR FAMILY GET IT ,IT WILL NOT BE TAXABLE .AS THERE IS NO PARTITION SUCH CAPITAL GAIN WILL BE TAXABLE IN THE HANDS OF HUF BUT NOT IN UR FAMILY HANDS

BUT IN THE ABOVE CASE U CANT CLAIM THE BENIFIT AS HUF AS U SAID THIS PROPERTY  IS INHERITED BY UR FATHER,SO IT IS NOT THE PROPERTY OF HUF.SO ANY GAIN ARISE ON WILL BE TAXABLE IN UR FAMILY BASED ON THEIR PROPORTIONS

FOR INDEXATION BENIFIT,I THOUGHT THE COST OF ACQUISITION SHALL BE COST TO THE PREVIOUS OWNER BUT NOT ON FAIR MARKET VALUE ON  1981

 

In our case a cost to previous owner is NIL.

  1. What should be the cost of property in question becoz original property was purchased in 1932.
  2. From when the indexation will start.
  3. Shall we taken payment in one name or equally divide the same in all 4 of us from the tax point of view?
  4. Myself and brother are having housing loans. Can we repay that loan from the amount of this transaction and avoid capital gain tax?


CCI Pro

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register