Don't encourage anyone to join in Chartered Accountancy!!!

Its not that ki CA as a course is bad

its jus that opportunies are decllning day by day

today in dainik bhaskar it was written that in 1980, 

80% passout practise and rest 20%go for job and now it is vice verse

its popularity increasing but value certanily decreasing

cheers

ITS ALL FINE FRIEND WHAT EVER THE POINTS U RAISED ARE DEFINITELY TRUE ... BUT U FORGET THE MAIN THEME OF THE CA COURESE .CA MEAN PRACTICE  FIRST AND NEXT WILL BE JOB BUT THE ADVANCEMENT OF SOME CORPORATE CULTURE IN THE LAST DECADE PEOPLE SHOWING MUCH INTEREST IN JOBS . SO BASING ON THIS IT DOEST MEAN THAT WHOEVER QUALIFED WILL GET JOB IS WORNG,DESPITE THE HUGE EFFORTS MADE TO BECOME CA WE MUST BEAR THESE FACTS . 

WHEN COMES TO EXPERIENCE DEFINITELY ITS A BIG PAIN FOR FRESHER IF ANY ONE ASKED FOR EXPERIENCE AT THE SAME TIME WE SHOULD NOT BLAME THE CORPORATES/ EMPLOYESS, IF THEY TAKE  A INEXPEREINCED THOUGH HE HAS 3 YEARS ARTICLES EXPERIENCE THEY HAVE TO SPENT SOME TIME TO GET THIS FRESHER TO ACUSTOMED TO ORGAINSATION EXPOSURE ON THE OTHER SIDE IF THEY TAKE A BIT EXPERIENCED THIS PROCESS WILL BE LESS IN THESE CRUNCH PERIODS SO THEY CAN SAVE SOME BUCKS .

U SAID WE SHOULD NOT ENCOURAGE THE OTHER TO JOIN IN CA .. BEST OF MY KNOWLEDGE NO ONE ENCOURAGE HIMSELF ANY ONE TO JOIN IN CA UNLESS HE/SHE IS VERY KEEN TO JOIN IN THE CA COURSE . IF OTHERS ARE INTERSTED TO JOIN HOW CAN WE DISCOURAGE THEM ITS OBSLOUTELY WRONG INSTEAD OF SAYING NOT TO JOIN IN CA , WE HAVE TO LIST THEM THESE ARE GOOD AND THOUGH THINGS TO BE FACED ONCE U JOIN AND ONE MORE FACT WE CAN NOT SOTP OTHER JOINING IN CA . I DONT WANT TO COMMENT ON ADVERTISEMENTS AS ITS PEOPLES DECISION WHETER TO RESPOND TO IT OR NOT .

AND LASTLY OPPURTUNITIES ARE ALWAYS LESS WE HAVE TO TRY A BIT HARDER .... WE CAN NOT WASTE OUR TIME FOR SEEKING A JOB IN BIG COMPANY WITH GOOD SALARY IN INITIAL PERIOD ITSELF ... WE MUST GRAB THE FIRST OPPURUNITY EVEN IN SMALL ORGANISATION LATER GAINING SOME EXPERIENCE  WE CAN MOVE TO OTHER COMPANIES. .

U SAID DONT DO IT ... BUT I SAY JUST DO IT FOR THE SAKE OF ACCOUNTING PROFESSION  

AND ONE MORE TIME, CA MEAN PRACTICE ..... DONT SAY WHAT ABOUT CLIENTS , INITIAL DAYS ARE TOUGH FOR EVERY ONE ... WE MUST START FORM FIRST STEP AND ADVACE TO NEXT LEVELS ... ITS BEEN PROVED  EXAMPLES ARE THE PRESENT DAY INDIAN COPPRATE FAMILES . 

BE POSTIVE .... ALWYAS ... THIS WILL FIND U A WAY 

REGARDS

TEJAN 

Rightly said Charanteja

This Worst condition is not only in the CA Profession CS,Engineering,MBA etc. most of the professional Course facing the same.

yes i agree with Srikanth
 

@ Srikanth,

Since you are just registered for CA final, will you come forward to help the existing students and members by discontinuing your further studies in CA ?

Am sure You wont to do it! Then who we are to discourage others to not to join CA ?

wht i feel is its not lack of opportunities for freshly qualified CA ,its that they dont want to start at a lesser salary and they dont take up jobs and prefer to wait and watch and wait for opportunity to knock their door,i know it wll raise many negative views,bt i hv come across many CA's (freshly qualified) who r in their airs and r not ready to take up job bcoz of less salary and prefer sitting at home,v all know during articleship v r not given a very good practical exposure (exceptions r always there) so hw can one expect a brk of 9-10 lacs,v got to hv some experience to b in that slab and for that v shud b ready to wrk at a lesser salary.i may b wrong bt these r my views.

so v cannot blame proffession bt v shud blame our thinking and everybody is free to follow and choose their own career so there shud b no point of encouraging or discouraging someone to join CA course.

I totally agree with shrikant aaj iss profession ki value ek degree course se jyada nahin rahi gayi hai.mere ek friend ne november 2011 main CA clear kiya hai aur usne ek CA  firm join ki aur jo salary use offer ki gayi woh tho only 6000-7000. toh aao iss profession ki aaj value samajh sakte hain.aur sabhi CA student Metro cities main jaa kar articleship nahin kar sakte hain.Toh woh metro cities ke CA atudent se barabari bahin kar sakte hain.Iss profession ki jo aaj value ghat ti jaa rahi hai uske liye ICAI khud jimmedar hai.Use student ke liye IIT-IIM ki tarah college khol kar Student ko practical knawledge provide karwani chahiye.Kyonki Jo parctical konwledge metro cities ke C.A. de sakte hain woh sab cities ke CA nahin de sakte hain kyonki na toh unke pass itna work hota hai.yahin reason hai ki jayadatar fresher yaa toh coaching  padakar apna kaam chala rahe yaa fir bahoot hi kum salary par kaam kar rahe hain.

I completely disagree with this thought  process -

1. Any profession will give you a platform to prove yourself. Having a CA degree is not the end of world and you cannot think that "OK I am a CA" and somebody will come and give the best paid job or best Job profile on Earth -  Best solution is  to take up whatever oppurtunity comes your way try to improve personally and professionally.
2. This is one of the best platforms to explore what u want as professional and as a person. It gives you insight into various aspects of Finance (I doubt any other course will have such comprehensive and well structured syllabus). But it is on us to decide whether we want to pass the exam and get a degree or be passionate about what we are doing and learn as much as we can(I am sure the second method ll help u pass any exam on earth without any fuss).
3. NOTHING IN THIS WORLD IS PERFECT FROM EVERYBODY'S PERSPECTIVE. CA PROFESSION IS NOT A EXCEPTION TO THIS POINT. - SO CHANGE YOUR PRESPECTIVE OF LOOKING AT THINGS BECAUSE NO MATTER WHATEVER PROFESSION YOU TAKE UP - "HOW U DO THINGS" IS IMPORTANT RATHER THAN "WHAT U DO"

Regards

Santosh

Yes i agree with you srikanth but ...

the solution for this problem is not restrict students to join in CA.

we have to find some ways to over come these situations

and

ICAI also has to take some steps to overcome this bad situations and it has to get good demand to our CA's in India level and in International level.

we all waiting a golden days for our CA's.

Regards,

Sri

Originally posted by : Santosh Ramaseshan
	I completely disagree with this thought  process - Any profession will give you a platform to prove yourself. Having a CA degree is not the end of world and you cannot think that "OK I am a CA" and somebody will come and give the best paid job or best Job profile on Earth -  Best solution is  to take up whatever oppurtunity comes your way try to improve personally and professionally. This is one of the best platforms to explore what u want as professional and as a person. It gives you insight into various aspects of Finance (I doubt any other course will have such comprehensive and well structured syllabus). But it is on us to decide whether we want to pass the exam and get a degree or be passionate about what we are doing and learn as much as we can(I am sure the second method ll help u pass any exam on earth without any fuss). NOTHING IN THIS WORLD IS PERFECT FROM EVERYBODY'S PERSPECTIVE. CA PROFESSION IS NOT A EXCEPTION TO THIS POINT. - SO CHANGE YOUR PRESPECTIVE OF LOOKING AT THINGS BECAUSE NO MATTER WHATEVER PROFESSION YOU TAKE UP - "HOW U DO THINGS" IS IMPORTANT RATHER THAN "WHAT U DO" Regards Santosh

Well said.

One more thing i would like to mention rather blaming to this profession we should create great capability in ourselves so that we can fullfill the requirement of this degree . As everybody knows CA is great and good profession but after qualifying CA course very few people are able to substanitiate this due to lack of communication skills, analytical skills, personality and all.

@ charanteja.nsr, Ram krishnan:

I have only said 'not to encourage anyone to join in CA', but not 'to disccourage any one from doing CA'.

I THINK WE SHOULD NOT GIVE SUCH BAD OPINIONS. I HAVE ALSO SEEN THAT NEWLY QUALIFIED CA IS NOT ABLE TO GET THE EXPECTED SALARY JOB. BUT MAIN REASON IS THAT CA ARE GETTING JOBS BUT THEY ARE NOT JOINING BECAUSE OF LESS SALARY. NEWLY QUALIFIED CA IS GETTING 20000 SALARY IN JALANDHAR (PUNJAB).BUT AFTER CA WE WANT THAT WE SHOULD GET ATLEAST 30000-40000.SO WE SHOULD NOT SAY THAT CA HAS NO VALUE. BETTER WE SHOULD START PRACTICE.RATHER TO WAIT FOR JOB. IF WE WANT TO GET REALLY PRACTICAL EXPERIENCE.IN ARTICLESHIP THERE IS NO MUCH PRACTICAL EXPOSURE.THERE MAY BE SOME STRUGGLE IN INITIAL YEAR. BUT FINALLY WE WILL FLY DEFINITELY.