LIVE GST Certification Course by CA Arun Chhajer begins 27th April. Register Now!!

Vinod agrawal audit book ca final

jaimin (Finance Executive) (465 Points)

09 August 2012

Dear all,

I had bought book of Vinod Agarwal for Auditing for CA final but i had found following things missing in the book

1. Prakhar shama has withdrown his name from book

2. the book has written it is updated but i am not able to found in the book new topics like Guidance note on revised schedule VI, appointment of Cost auditor etc. the same were present in another refernce book

do any bady find this topics any where in the book

Reply
Follow
Share

9 Replies

CA Revati Galgali (B.com ACA DipIFR(ACCA) CS(Exe)) (1049 Points)
Replied 09 August 2012

I think u will find the guidance notes under the company audit and other relevant chapters and Cost audit procedure is given under "Cost audit under the companies act" on Page 306.

I hope ur talking abt the Jul 2012 edition

jaimin (Finance Executive) (465 Points)
Replied 09 August 2012

thanks for responding Revati & yes u r right i found the answer on page 306

yes i am talking about the July 2012 edition only. But where is Guidance note on revised schedule VI.

CA Revati Galgali (B.com ACA DipIFR(ACCA) CS(Exe)) (1049 Points)
Replied 10 August 2012

If you go through the list of publications applicable for NOV 2012 Exam, you will not find guidance note on Rev Sch VI applicable for us either in FR or in Audit. So I think, its not required to be a part of the book.

S. AGGARWAL (STUDENT) (315 Points)
Replied 10 August 2012

hi jaimin I was plannin to buy d same book.. I'l be grateful if u cud tell me d following things.. What is d way of presentation, does it cover case study based ques and past ppr ques.. And is it better dan paduka.?:)

jaimin (Finance Executive) (465 Points)
Replied 10 August 2012

thanks Revati

1 Like

CA Revati Galgali (B.com ACA DipIFR(ACCA) CS(Exe)) (1049 Points)
Replied 12 August 2012

Originally posted by : SABI AGGARWAL
	hi jaimin I was plannin to buy d same book.. I'l be grateful if u cud tell me d following things.. What is d way of presentation, does it cover case study based ques and past ppr ques.. And is it better dan paduka.?:)

In my opinion, nothing can be better than paduka, but if u keep the time constraint in mind, assuming that you shall appear for both groups, its advisable to follow Agrawal. But personally i feel Padhuka is the best but very exhaustive.