Continuous 6 time failure in pcc- urgent suggestions require

IPCC 4520 views 44 replies

Hello Everyone,

I am here to have everyones advice on the case of my best friend who have failed PCC 6 times. She workes hard a lot , each time passed in every subject bt always remain in aggregate wd 10 marks ( May12).

Now she has finally decided to quit and refusing to fill the exam form for Nov 12. We both have started the journery of CA together. N its very sad for me that my mate has not cleared PCC yet. sad

She took reference of all the good material , done RTP and practice manuals.. even her papers gone good. But here is the failure again.

According to her, "CA is not in her luck now.. What she has studied at PCC level is none of matter now as per IPCC level. All the questions are on conceptual basis now which was not earlier."

Moreover I guess in further attmpts IPCC will be compulsion for PCC ones also.

She want to utilise her further time in any other degree or course.
I dont want her to quit from this failure. After my motivation only she became confident till this 6th atempt. But now her patience power seems to be fail.

Daily I am going to her home to make her understand but I am fail. broken heart

Main part is that she really deserves to be a CA according to her interesr, intelligence etc. But I am not able to make her confident again. 

Please tell me what I can do for her so that along with me she also become CA. May be by all your suggestions I can make her agree again. 

Thanks in advance.

Replies (44)

hi,

         Really it's very disappointed to fail in the pcc exams 6 times. Every one will get depressed and want to quit the CA. This is not a surprising effect which comes to your friend.

She has attempted many times. Only the one thing I want to tell you that the mistake is done in our part not at the institute part. We have to find out the mistake which your friend is doing regularly in the exams.

Whatever preparation you have done, doesn't matter if you will not reflect your hardworking in the answer sheet. Examiner only know your answer sheet. Nothing more he knows about you.

Whether your friend writing long and useless answer with the correct answer in the exams, not solving the answer of accounts and taxation in the proper format, not writing the question number for which she is answering before starting the answer, using some spiritual words like "Jai Mata di" at the top of the copy, not starting the new answer with new page, over studying during the exam day and stressing herself before the exams, not preparing herself according to the exam pattern. These are the some common problems which is done by the students and suffer loosing of marks.

As now, you can do only one thing that you should recognize the mistake done by her in exams by calling his answer sheet from institute and if you will find out the mistake, then she will get the confidence  to pass the CA exam.

So Best wishes and hope to clear CA exams this time.

As the last day of filing exam form is 28th of this month. And right now calling for answer sheet would take more time. 

Acording to her view, she took care of above all mentioned things. Thats why its too difficult for me to make her agree this time. broken heart

Hi Pooja,

Great efforts has been put by you to make your friend give one more attempt over & over again...

I suggest you to ask her this one attempt for your sake...

I completely agree with your friend how it feels after so many attempts, I took almost similar number of attempts to clear PCC but just because some of my friends encouraged me (the way you do for friend so i gave last in may with God's grace i cleared...

So just for your sake ask her to give attempt....n ask her not to loose patience...wish her all the very best..

 

this will depend upon your understanding that how you prepare her to fill exam form, as you take a step ahead for her. you purchase a form for her, fill it as much as possible and try to agree her. Tell her that the time, she spend on the ca till now will lost, if she left the CA now. Just give one more attempt and prove yourself.

Hi Pooja,

Its good to see that you are concerned about your friend very much. Tell your friend that everything happened has some sort of goodness in it. These 6 failures may now lead to passing exam with good marks.

 

She needs to fill the form first, and then she can pursue any other course as desired by her. This exam can be given simultaneously. If she passes then O.K., otherwise her other cousre will be going on... 

Originally posted by : CA Amit Sinha

Hi Pooja,

Its good to see that you are concerned about your friend very much. Tell your friend that everything happened has some sort of goodness in it. These 6 failures may now lead to passing exam with good marks.

 

She needs to fill the form first, and then she can pursue any other course as desired by her. This exam can be given simultaneously. If she passes then O.K., otherwise her other cousre will be going on... 

Sir I already gave her this advice to start any course simulataneously. She is saying either of banking sector exams or mba etc.

This time also if she give then she will give one group only. We have seen this dream of being CA together. N I will give my best to prepare her so that we both fly together in the corporate world as CA.

Can anyone let me know is there really a big difference in the paper pattern of PCC and IPCC ?
Shud she give extra efforts to cope up with this failure from syllabus point of view?

Secondly is there any notification by the ICAI that PCC students compulsorily transfer to IPCC after couple of attempts and the they have to study one more extra subject (Advance Accounting) too.

hey pooja,

I wud just like to say dat i cleared my 1st group of pcc in 4th attemp and 2nd group in 5th attempt.. But one of my frnd just cleared wid me now...bth d grups it was her 6th attemtp and u knw wat she got 41st in all over india... it was really surprising for her...u really don't know wat god has kept for u in d box...tell her to other thngs too nd simultaneously giv xams...2more attempts r left for pcc....

 

 

Please ask her to do meditation and concentrate in studies.. donot compare with others...

Hi pooja Gupta Good eveng very nice to meet u here ... because u r quoting here for ur friend... see If a person fail with 10 marks or 20 marks diff.. it means he know concept vert well but problem is lack of presentation..so u give her a question paper of any year wich she wrote exam and u correct the paper with suggested answer then u and she will come to know wer u r getteing mistake...see I ll give a best example one of my friend who is pcc wrote 6 times exam and every time he get below 150(both groups)but after 4 attemsts he known that mistake is in lack of presentation his articles completed so tht he strt preparaion with a gud dedication and he got all indi 25th rank.. this is fact why am saying here is  dont say her Quit CA ok,. Einstein fails 23 times to provve a formula bt in every time he learn some thing and finally he got success so all the best and say het to try for rank not pass becoz I think she is strong in concept and subject

ACTUALLY SHE CAN CONTINUE WIT PCC SYLLABUS SIS...

FROM DATE OF REGISTRATION 4YRS WE CAN TRY THE ATTEMPT..

IF NOT OLY REREGISTRATION REQUIRED..

THERE WONT B NEED 4 REREGISTRATION AS UR FRND LL SURELY CLEAR THIS TIME...

SO AS OF NOW THERE IS NO NEED 4 THINKING IPCC SYLLABUS..

ITS MY KIND REQUEST NOT TO QUIT CA AS THE TIME SHE SPENT THIS MUCH HARD TO ACHIEVE LL GO WASTE IN A MIN...

ALL THE BEST SISyes

HATS OFF TO U FOR UR ENCOURAGEMENT..smiley

I can understand what she is going through coz I myself cleared my pcc 1st group in my 6th attempt and in 7th attempt I failed coz of 2marks I secured 148 marks in may 2012 I felt so bad i went into total depression, my inner voice started talking to me " you fear if you won't prepare well " this is last attempt of pcc I still had 80days to go for it and I failed just becoz of 2marks so my knowledge on subject is good I didn't revised so many times for my exam I'm preparing well for my exam I don't care whether there are more pcc attempts or not but it's my last pcc attempt. I know the pain what my parents feel if I dropped the course in half way I know the passion I Had towards the subject, I won't stay happy me being not able to clear CA I just want to forget my past I want to clear my nov 2012attempt and go to swapneal patni classes for isca.. Common yaar tell her 80days to go for exams just 1attempt put ur whole life into it. Smartness and intelligence of a person can carry a person to 140marks but proper preparation and presentation will make it clear 150marks. Ask her to keep hope see the future if she just clears it off she will be in CA final which she dreams of in last 3years.. Don't look at the past

 

As the last day of filing exam form is 28th of this month. And right now calling for answer sheet would take more time. 

Acording to her view, she took care of above all mentioned things. Thats why its too difficult for me to make her agree this time. broken heart

Pooja the last date of form fill up is 27th of this month, n tell ur frd ke May 2012 ka verification ke liye de de n this will cost only 100 per paper and side by side tell her to fill november exam form also, shw will/can do it, Only God is checking her patience, Sai Baba will surely help hew

Originally posted by : Pooja Gupta

As the last day of filing exam form is 28th of this month. And right now calling for answer sheet would take more time. 

Acording to her view, she took care of above all mentioned things. Thats why its too difficult for me to make her agree this time. 

Pooja the last date of form fill up is 27th of this month, n tell ur frd ke May 2012 ka verification ke liye de de n this will cost only 100 per paper and side by side tell her to fill november exam form also, shw will/can do it, Only God is checking her patience, Sai Baba will surely help hew


CCI Pro

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register