in SOLLUTION GIVEN BY ICAI OF Q. N 18 of of value added statement (RTP NOV'12)... excise duty is not considered in
cost of bought in material... rather it is shown in govt payments..... is it right???
Menu
Confusion in rtp nov'12
Replies (4)
Yes, you can follow either of approach
Note must be written for the same.............
me to had similar prob so i had mail praveen sharma sir mail nd reply are as under;:
hii sir
sir can u pls mail me the correct sol of rtp q 18 (value added statement)...
sir i had following problem in that ques or rather contrast with rtp ans
ED treatment -not as per our class assumption
application statement is made only for 4 people (why not 6)
loss on sale of fixed asset -why not treated as extraordinary item in VAS
reply
Dear Student
Here the treatment of Excise duty is not correct you should follow the concept provided in the class. If there information related to any party out of 6 parties not available then you have option to leave it.
Sale of old fixed assets is not extraordinary since we have already separeted depreciation amount every year and we know that the fixed assets will be scraped after a certain period.
Regards
ETEN CA
Academic Team
in acc rtp q 16 360000 should be 320000???????????
Recent Topics :
- 12A registration expired in FY 22-23 and is not re
- Seeking Clarification on Business Code Selection a
- CG on property sold after construction of a house
- Nursing Home Taxability
- CA opted for Form 10IEA mistakenly - Demand raised
- Query on scenario related to FAST DS 2026
- Audit Executive (Remote, India) - Ace Auditing Off
- GST Transaction On Used Clothing
- ITC availed on 5%-rate passenger transport (AC bus
- Extension of Due Date of AY 2026-27
Related Topics :
09 September 2026
Semi Qualified CA / CA Inter - 2 Groups Cleared
Getmyca Consultant Pvt Ltd
New Delhi
CA Inter
View Details
ARTICLESHIP
18 September 2026
Industrial Trainee
Twenty Point Nine Five Ventures Private Limited
Noida
CA Inter
View Details
22 September 2026
Account Assistant
Chirag P Shah & Co. Chartered Accountant
Pune
B.Com
View Details
09 September 2026
SENIOR AUDITOR & ACCOUNTS MANAGER
Anupam Parashar & Co.
Ghaziabad
CA Final
View Details
CCI
Pro
CAclubindia
