Confusion betn 194c/i

 

 
In various cases, a dispute has arisen as to whether a contract is a contract of work or contract of hiring since different rate of TDS has been provided u/s 194C/194I. In the case of Indian Oil Corporation,the assessee entered into contracts with transporters for transporting petroleum products from the plant to various destinations. It deducted TDS u/s 194C at 2% on the basis that the transportation contract was contract of “work”. However, the AO held that the contract was a “hiring” of vehicles on the basis that (i) the assessee had exclusive possession and usage, (ii) the use was for a fixed tenure, (iii) the tankers were customized to the assessee’s requirements and that TDS ought to have been u/s 194-I at 10%. The tribunal has held that it was a contract of work in terms of section 194C and not a contract of hiring u/s 194I by observing as under:-

To decide whether a contract is one for “transportation” or for “hiring”, the crucial thing is to see who is doing the transportation work. If the assessee takes the trucks and does the work of transportation himself, it would amount to hiring. However, if the services of the carrier were used and the payment was for actual transportation work, the contract is for transportation of goods and not an arrangement for hiring of vehicles. On facts, the agreement was of the nature of transport agreement and not one for hiring of vehicles because the tank truck owners did not simply confine themselves to providing vehicles at the disposal of the assessee in lieu of rent but also engaged their drivers in driving such vehicles and thereby in transporting petroleum products from one place to the other. In effect, the truck remained in the possession of the staff of the carrier. Further, the assessee was required to pay for the transportation work on the basis of distance and no idle charges were payable. There was no transfer of the right to use the vehicle involved in the agreement. The agreement was merely for carriage of petroleum products and so s. 194-I was not applicable.



In my opinion, right decision has been taken by the tribunal and the readers would be benefited by the same.
 

 

Replies (2)

Thanks for posting....

Thanks .

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register  

Company
Featured 29 October 2026
Accounts Executive

Synergy Keystone

Chennai

B.Com

View Details
Company
16 November 2026
Assistant Article

ZAK & Co. Chartered Accountants

Bengaluru

CA Inter

View Details
Company
14 November 2026
Manager - Indirect Tax (GST)

Westbridge Consulting LLP

New Delhi

CA

View Details
Company
Featured ARTICLESHIP 28 October 2026
CA- Inter and Articles

N N V Satish & Co.,

Hyderabad

CA Inter

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 07 November 2026
Article Assisstant

DPV & Associates

Chennai

CA Inter

View Details
Company
24 October 2026
CA Industrial Trainee

Fytomax Nutrition Private Limited

Aurangabad

CA Inter

View Details
Company
Featured ARTICLESHIP 31 October 2026
CA Articleship

apricus india

Navi Mumbai

CA Inter

View Details
Company
Featured 07 November 2026
Paid Assisstant

DPV & Associates

Chennai

CA Inter

View Details