Communication u/s 143(1)(a)

Originally posted by : Kapil Aggarwal
	Hello Friends, Has Anyone got any response from Income tax after submitting the response to 143(1)a.

Not yet.

@ Pushpreet  you must ask your Employer to change his form 16.

143(1)(a) is system based reply given by computer and not Humans.

Form 16 should contain salaried part and other income  part

Hi all, any one return processed after 143()(a) response ?

NOT YET PROCESSED AFTER FILING RESPONSE

No response received, still waiting....

Originally posted by : CA.Pullarao Padakandla
	Hi all, any one return processed after 143()(a) response ?

No response yet.

Finally its processed for me & my wife.

Hi Shibin,

Any specefic format email you have received from Income tax department, Did your ITR processed after denied to the demand ? Please advise need your help on this. Thanks.

I have received following email --> 

Intimation U/S 143(1) for PAN AxxxxxxxR AY:2017-18

processed for my several clients..... they got their desired refunds also...

Hi Kapil,

1st i had received communication u/s 143(1)(a) communication.

Then I have responded to it by denying that and uploaded all the documents.

Now I got "Intimation U/S 143(1) for PAN...." message and next day refund also credited to my account.

It means your return has been processed

Thanks Right CA. Its completed for me and my spouse.

yes, if u have proper justification with proof, then they are crediting refunds

Originally posted by : shobhit
	yes, if u have proper justification with proof, then they are crediting refunds

I'm not at all suggesting that anyone should try this but, something funny happened with me that I would like to share;

I too got Communication u/s 143(1) (https://www.caclubindia.com/forum/details.asp?mod_id=410813&offset=8) 2 months back and I went ahead with e-proceeding to disagree with the proposed addition.

I got the proposed addition because I didn't delcare a 80C deduction of tution of children with the employer (form 16) but claimed it while filing the return.

The funny thing happened is that I gathered all the challans supporting my additional 80C claim and compiled it in a word document and saved it as Doc(x) in my computer but while uploading in e-Proceedings, I uploaded a totally different file! It contained totally irrelevent details to my claim and there was no other option to revert it. I then thought they would send another communication or something but surprisngly last week I got intimation stating that they have processed my return and refund will be done as well!

I'm pretty sure they have not verified the file that I've attached. Anyway I'm happy that it's over and I don't have to go behind it again.

Just wanted you guys to know. I'm sorry if it is totally irrelevent to this thread.

Yes you are right :) its happend to one of my client as well ...