Commodities related transaction

dear colleagues
gud noon
ek client hai mere jinhe commodities trading me 175500/- ka short term loss hua hai... toh unka turnover kaise calculate kru or iss show kaise kru

regards
Replies (9)
Quick Summary
This discussion clarifies how to handle short-term losses in commodities trading. Transactions without delivery are treated as business income and the loss should be declared under the PGBP head. Turnover for F&O transactions is calculated by aggregating all favourable and unfavourable differences (profit/loss), including premiums on option sales and differences from reverse trades. Even with only two trades resulting in a total loss of £175,837, this figure represents both the business loss and the turnover, which can be set off against other business income except salary.

The transaction without delivery basis are treated as business income.

the loss should be declared under PGBP head.

The turnover in case of F&O transaction to be computed as below:

(i) The total of favorable and unfavorable differences (Profit/Loss) shall be taken as turnover.

(ii) Premium received on sale of options is also to be included in turnover.

(iii) In respect of any reverse trades entered, the difference thereon, should also form part of the turnover.

Please note whether the difference is profit or loss it will not make any difference, and all the difference aggregated to compute the turnover.

Toh sir hua toh short term loss hai toh usse as a business loss hi show kru.. kyunki transaction without delivery base per hi hai.. tabhi toh turnover 4 crore hai... mtlb buy or sell crore me hai

1. This is treated as business income.

2. Turnover is to be calculated as per guidelines issued by ICAI, (as explained earlier). It will be lesser than the 4cr.

Ok sir... ek last confusion.. usse ek trade me 10380/- ka loss hua or next trade me 165457/-... bss usne year me 2 trade hi liye the.. toh uska turnover 175837/- Or business loss bhi 175837/- hi hua correct hai na sir??

Correct...                       first positive turnover           second same figure but negative.

In case he has any other business income than this loss can be set off with any other income except salary.

Ok guruji thank you so much.. toh meri ye calculation sahi hai na??
or sir aapke koi contact num. Ho toh de do ... yha per roj bahut confusion hota hai... aapko kabhi call krke distrub toh nhi krunga lekin query whatsapp jarur kr dunga

You can post the query in expert section, there this confusion will not arise. You will get authentic reply.

Ok guruji🙏🙏

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register  

Company
07 October 2026
Senior Account Manager

Amplio Invest

Mumbai

M.Com

View Details
Company
Featured ARTICLESHIP 06 October 2026
Semi Qualified

AJAY SINGH AND CO LLP

Thane

CA Final

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 22 October 2026
Articleship intern

Srinath Manikanta

Hyderabad

CA Inter

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 07 October 2026
Article Assistant

Malhotra Rajesh & Associates

New Delhi

B.Com

View Details
Company
08 October 2026
Account Executive

Elite Taxation

New Delhi

CA Foundation

View Details
Company
12 October 2026
Finance

I-Genext Consulting Private Limited

New Delhi

CA

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 17 October 2026
Articled Assistant

RRPM & Associates LLP

Chennai

CA Inter

View Details
Company
06 October 2026
Assistant Manager - Audit and Compliance

Ravi K Jain & Co

Noida

Others

View Details