Anjali Upadhyayk (14 Points)
16 April 2019
CA PRIYANSH SURYAWANSHI
(M.Com M.A. Economics CA)
(1294 Points)
Replied 16 April 2019
Unfortunately, you can not appear for Nov 2019 attempt.
Anjali Upadhyayk
(14 Points)
Replied 16 April 2019
CA PRIYANSH SURYAWANSHI
(M.Com M.A. Economics CA)
(1294 Points)
Replied 17 April 2019
BKC??? Are you talking about ICAI Mumbai, Bandra Kurla Complex?
In my opinion, you can not.. One has to mandatorily complete 2.5 years of articleship before the Final attempt and 2.5 years INCLUDES excess leaves
So as per your given details, You have joined on 28.04.2017, so 2.5 years complete on 27.10.2019...
But when you add 67 days excess leaves you get 27.10.2019+67 = 02.01.2020
Hence you are not eligible for Nov 2019 attempt
Reconfirm it...
Anjali Upadhyayk
(14 Points)
Replied 17 April 2019
CA PRIYANSH SURYAWANSHI
(M.Com M.A. Economics CA)
(1294 Points)
Replied 17 April 2019
Tell me one thing
When you received letter of transfer from ICAI, did it mention EXCESS LEAVES Of 67 days?? I am asking about Excess, not total leaves taken by you...
I will tell you one thing now which even most of the ICAI members are not aware of and students suffer when they apply for CA Final
156 days leaves are granted by ICAI no doubt, but these leaves are proportional to no of days you have worked so far... That means 52 per year
so if you have worked for 1 year and have taken 70 leaves in total (example) you have taken 18 excess leaves. Now it has nothing to do with your total no of leaves i.e., 156
One more thing, this problem arises only with those students who have taken transfer during 3 years and have excess leaves... If you have any doubt let me know
I am sure you are not eligible for your attempt if ICAI has given you excess leaves...
Anjali Upadhyayk
(14 Points)
Replied 17 April 2019
CA PRIYANSH SURYAWANSHI
(M.Com M.A. Economics CA)
(1294 Points)
Replied 17 April 2019
Look I agree with what you are saying
But the problem with students with a transfer is that Once you have been given excess leaves, that can not be settled with future articleship days... So basically what you are saying is correct but in the end, no settlement is done...
Still, If ICAI is saying this I would endorse it.
I may be wrong I am not saying that, but what I am saying is based on my own and most of my friends experiences and a lot of R&D done on this issue...
You can go with ICAI no issues with that
Please tell me what happens when you fill your exam form... It would be a good thing to know
I hope you get your attempt
Best wishes
Anjali Upadhyayk
(14 Points)
Replied 17 April 2019
CA PRIYANSH SURYAWANSHI
(M.Com M.A. Economics CA)
(1294 Points)
Replied 17 April 2019
Actually what happens is You will fill the form and it would be accepted. After some days they will send you a letter that you are not eligible for this attempt due to this calculation of excess leaves...
So I am still firm with my words on this issue, But if ICAI people are saying that you are eligible thn I can't comment on this...
You can take a risk
CA PRIYANSH SURYAWANSHI
(M.Com M.A. Economics CA)
(1294 Points)
Replied 17 April 2019
I Know one of the worst case
My friend filled exam form, he was allowed to write the exam and on the day of result, he got a letter that your result is withheld due to non-eligibility...
I have told you all the possible scenarios
Aditya thakur
(Student)
(23 Points)
Replied 13 August 2019
CAclubindia
