CA Final AMA paper May 2018

ishmeet

student

27 Points Posted on 10 May 2018

Costings marks should be evaluated from 5 question . As it cant be completed on time😓.

Keshab Roy

Student CA Final

32 Points Posted on 10 May 2018

Conceptual and lengthy.

Papar was easy, but don't know why they use to ask such kind of paper where almost 90% of students are unable to attempt 30- 40 marks every time. Not only that the evaluation procedure is also tough in AMA paper. There should be panel who can verify whether paper setters are able to complete the same paper on time.

Anantha Krishna

17 Points Posted on 10 May 2018

Question paper was actually easy. There were barely any unexpected questions or new questions except theory which was a tad bit different than usual. Given 4 hours I think most would've got exemption in this paper. Time management was key.

Paavithra

Student

47 Points Posted on 10 May 2018

All the questions were from practice manual.Questions were slightly modified. A good start to group 2.

chhaya

senior accountant

29 Points Posted on 10 May 2018

Lengthy and dirty simplex questions

Sourabh

hisar

26 Points Posted on 10 May 2018

Very lengthy paper....not completed

ankish mishra

Student CA Final

22 Points Posted on 10 May 2018

It was too lengthy, I don't understand what's the point of going so lengthy paper. Instead they could make paper little more conceptual but less lengthy

nitin nayyar

student

366 Points Posted on 10 May 2018

Guys mail icai.. They have started this initiative for paper feedback.. Mail them in tons. I know they will not listen.. But this is only we can do.

ronit

--

24 Points Posted on 11 May 2018

Way too lengthy, we need to have super power within ourself to solve the whole paper in 3 hours.
I dont know if anyone out there has attempted 100 marks paper?

Richa Maheshwari

Student CA Final

245 Points Posted on 11 May 2018

Can anyone tell whether gross investment or net investment after deducting current liabilities was to be taken for calculation of return on capital employed in question 2 b??

V S Ramesh

Pres (F)

24 Points Posted on 11 May 2018

Incase the steps are correctly written but couldn't complete the answer due to time will I get mark for steps Read more at: https://www.caclubindia.com/forum/ca-final-ama-paper-may-2018-461694.asp

Ganesh Prasad Acharya

Student

27 Points Posted on 11 May 2018

Net working capital is relevant for calculation of return.

Prabhava P Hegde

student

34 Points Posted on 11 May 2018

YES.

Please send mail to ICAI they will consider your comments on such a papers..

shresthanis123

CA student

33 Points Posted on 11 May 2018

Is it me only who find the paper tough😓😓😓

Menu

ishmeet

Keshab Roy

Bhagyesh

Anantha Krishna

Paavithra

chhaya

Sourabh

ankish mishra

nitin nayyar

ronit

Richa Maheshwari

V S Ramesh

Ganesh Prasad Acharya

Prabhava P Hegde

shresthanis123

Leave a Reply

Recent Threads

Related Threads

Latest Job Openings

Senior Executive

Manager- Finance and Compliance

GST CONSULTANT

GST CONSULTANCY

Accountant

CA Final

Article Assistant

Associate CA

Menu

Forum Search

CA Final AMA paper May 2018

Leave a Reply

Recent Threads

Related Threads