For AS: Yes, ds rawat fine only for theory and its easy to read bcoz for some of AS, content is less. 1 more problem in rawat is very less illatrations which are not at al enough for CA FINAL. So, go with padhuka for AS..without missing one, it contains all past examinations questions and all old RTP questions. U wil nt get old rtp questions(whch are very important) any other author except padhuka.