Tally

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Jeetendra (Professional)     18 December 2010

BOOK FOR SFM: PATTABHI RAM OR SRIDHAR ???

Dear CCI Friends,

Firstly, I must mention that 'CCI Really Rockss'. Ok now I would like you all to help me out on this. I've finalised almost all subjects' books for my CA Final exams but I just can't decide a book for Strategic Financial Management. The confusion is mainly between two books - Pattabhi Ram/SD Bala & A.N.Sridhar. I would like u all to tell me which would be better suited for my exam preparations. My attempt is due in May 2011 & I'm opting for self study for this subject. It would be great if u could also tell me the pros & cons of each book....

Awaiting ur Expert Advice....

Thanx in advance.....



 17 Replies

 CA.CWA.Venkatesh Repala

CA.CWA.Venkatesh Repala (CA CWA;(CS PROFESSIONAL))     18 December 2010

I always prefer Pattabhi ram.

Devi Kala

Devi Kala (Chartered Accountant)     18 December 2010

For Self study, SD Bala & Pattabhiram is best... I too have the same book ... It gives u a good conceptual knowlege... While u read the book, u will feel that some one is teaching u...

Jeetendra

Jeetendra (Professional)     19 December 2010

Plz guyz, I need some more support....

My decision will be based on ur views.....

So plz tell me fast which book should I go for & why....

Jithin

Jithin (Learner)     19 December 2010

Dear Jeetendra, I am referring Pattabhiraman. Have given below some of its merits & demerits.

 

Merits

 

1)Ideal book for self study.

 

2)Explains concepts really well. 

 

3)Language is very simple & clear. This book is a pleasure to read.

 

4)When we read this book, we get the feeling that we are actually attending classes.

 

5)After explaining each concept, there is one simple problem based on that concept. This helps in really understanding the concepts.

 

 

Drawbacks

 

1)The problems given at the end of each chapter(except capital budgeting) are very simple. We dont get such simple problems in exams.

 

2)For the theory part, u cant rely on this book(theory is covered upto 20-30 marks in the exams, so is very important). 

 

3)Some of the solutions in the book contradict with those given in the compilation.

 

My Opinion 

Since u are doing self study, buy Pattabhiraman. In my opinion, its a must have for every student doing self study. But dont rely fully on it. Use it to understand concepts but do problems from compilation. If u can afford, also buy any book containing lots of problems(e.g.Paduka) & practise solving problems thereunder. For theory, u may refer to our module(if u have enough patience & endurance). If u are buying a book for problem solving purpose, u can refer that book for theory too(ensure that the book u are buying deals with both theory & problems).

 

Note:I havent read AN Sridhar so cant comment on it. Have heard that this book expains concepts well & have good number of problems.

 

Regards,

Jithin 

CA.ViVeK M ACA

CA.ViVeK M ACA (ACCOUNTS DEPARTMENT)     19 December 2010

You can refer V Pattabi Ram book..it is a better book. You can also refer aditya jain book for this subject it is also a right choice. makkar sir book is also a good one

Jeetendra

Jeetendra (Professional)     20 December 2010

Thank u Venkatesh & Devi...

Thanx Jithin for the detailed analysis & Thank u Vivek Sir for ur valuable suggestion....

@ Vivek Sir: Is Makkar Sir's Book available in soft copy???

Jeetendra

Jeetendra (Professional)     05 February 2011

Can anyone plz upload Makkar Sir's notes ???
Sushant Lohani

Sushant Lohani (CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT)     05 February 2011

Aditya jain's book can be downloaded from his website.Email to his company;they will mail u back the books.

Naveen.N

Naveen.N (student)     22 April 2011

How can we avail Aditya Jain;s Book

Rahul Bansal

Rahul Bansal (Finalist)     19 December 2011

 

     

Subject : Strategic Financial Management
               (Final)
 (New Syllabus)
               Management Accounting & Financial Analysis 
               (Final)
 (Old Syllabus)
Author  : V.Pattabhi Ram & S.D.Bala
 

 

mannoj

mannoj (striving for success)     19 December 2011

for concept wise - pattabhi 

and

for problems- sridhar.

regards

Ellaalan

Ellaalan (Manager)     22 December 2011

Originally posted by : CA.CWA.Venkatesh Repala
I always prefer Pattabhi ram.

Anit Sharma

Anit Sharma (CA Final student )     22 December 2011

a n shridhar

    

                                                                 

              

amit kumar

amit kumar (CA-Final)     09 July 2014

GO FOR AN SRIDHAR V GUD FOR CONCPETS ND THEORY ALSO HAVE Very NICE COLLECTION OF PRACTICAL PROBLEMS

Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register  


Start a New Discussion

Popular Discussion


view more »







Subscribe to the latest topics :
Search Forum:



Trending Tags