Whether an auditor can be appointed as an auditors of lilavati hospital ltd if he is indebted to company for Rs.7 Lacs for medical treatment of his father...?
another question is as follows:
whether the Rs.5 Lac limit of indebtedness is separate for each of the Company, it's holding, it's subsidiary, subsidiary of such holding company, and associate company ?
Menu
Auditors appointment us 141
Replies (6)
Quick Summary
Whereas the auditor can perform the audit under the principle of professional competence, the auditor should avoid situations that may become threats to compliance with the fundamental principles, for example self interest.
No, the auditor cannot be appointed in Lilavati hospital as he is indebted for 7 lakh rupees which is in excess of 500000 rupees.
No, the limit is not seperated. If the auditor indebted for
5 lakhs rupees in any of the subsidiary, holding or associate company, then he is ineligible to be appointed as auditor
No, the limit is not seperated. If the auditor indebted for
5 lakhs rupees in any of the subsidiary, holding or associate company, then he is ineligible to be appointed as auditor
I think the auditor can be appointed, but its his duty to put it into consideration that there might be a conflict of interest which might override the audit opinion. the immediate solution if the appointment is made is to declare the conflict of interest and maybe get an audit partner to handle the audit.
Ok thanks. and I think limit of indebtedness of 5 Lacs limit is for the entire group.
In my opinion, Commercial transactions in ordinary course of business at arms length price are not to be considered as Indebtness..
but over this if you think that it might affect your Independence, avoid such appointment..
but over this if you think that it might affect your Independence, avoid such appointment..
But in this case Auditor cannot be appointed
Recent Topics :
- TDS on payment to a non resident
- NSFA(National Food Security Act) commission
- RCM applicability on petty GTA freight (₹450
- Short payment reccieved in export & GST implic
- Parag Gupta vs Purushottam Aggarwal- who is best f
- GST applicability on own-vehicle goods transportat
- FAST DS Scheme 26
- 12A registration expired in FY 22-23 and is not re
- Seeking Clarification on Business Code Selection a
- CG on property sold after construction of a house
Related Topics :
09 September 2026
Semi Qualified CA / CA Inter - 2 Groups Cleared
Getmyca Consultant Pvt Ltd
New Delhi
CA Inter
View Details
ARTICLESHIP
21 September 2026
CA Article Assistant
KK & Company Chartered Accountant
Pune
CA Inter
View Details
CCI
Pro
CAclubindia
