Accounting of loss of work role life

We ,aluminiun sheet plant, are importing work roll, conventionally treated as capex , somewhere opex.

If rolls get undersized due to machining issue  there is loss of work roll life

Is it a revenue exp or be adjusted in capitalisation?

Settlement by credit note or reducing unit price...which is ideally correct?

Please guide

Replies (6)
Quick Summary
This discussion explores the accounting treatment for the loss of work roll life in an aluminium sheet plant. When imported work rolls are damaged due to machining issues, leading to a reduced lifespan, the key question is whether this loss should be treated as a capital expenditure (capex) or operational expenditure (opex). The debate centres on how to account for compensation from the exporter, either by adjusting the unit price or through a credit note, to accurately reflect the financial impact.

After you manufacture? Yes settlement with reimbursement and reducing price afterwards will help. Coming to scrappage, conversion costs include direct expenses and waste is a direct expense. So it can be capitalised. To be sure I will go through costing gaap and get back if anything different is mentioned. 

This import buy is from USA. Due to machining issue(eg specs mismatch), though this can be used at Indian buyers plant but with a lower economic life period.

There are 2 arguments.

One school of thought wants to adjust exporter's offer of compensation towards a loss of life,,in unit price itself.. 

My reading..

As life of work roll is linked to its usage in production  and not in terms of year,, importer should account for PO defined value and compensation (by credit note, ad shipment has already taken place and agreement of this compensation amt takes place later on --so no back end Invoice correction) in the books of account separately...to give a true reflection of both the incidences.

However  I am not having Accounting standard,

Institute guideline/ advisory,,case laws,,leading audit firms view points), IFRS , COST ACCOUNTING STD etc

Kindly guide me.

https://icmai.in/upload/Students/Syllabus-2008/StudyMaterial/Cost_Mgmt_Ac.pdf

Please follow this. I also studied many text books and this is pretty easy to understand. In page 34-35 you have the info.

the control accounts here is easy to understand. It’s reliable as it’s icmai publication. 

I did not understand me thing though, what is useful life? Who is manufacturing? Is anyone manufacturing in India? I want to know exactly what product it is please. 

 

Thank you.

This is work roll, used in aluminium sheet plant.

USA based Union Electric ,Akers manufacture this.

There is no manufacturer of such rolls in India.

Life of roll is unlike calendar years. It depends upon usage say one roll can produce 1 lakh tone of aluminium sheets.

Trust I am clear.

I am from Kolkata

Thank you For the details. Shelf life is not our cost accounting. It is capitalised into closing inventory as warehousing charges are related to production. This inventories standard authors are also mentally ill because storage costs are necessary. Before another production stage? All costs are absorbed and it is necessary. You can follow IndAS 2 for standards. 

No standard however mentions about the reality- I have seen those rolls while travelling on trains. They are lying there for years. But they are used after five years. Then the storage costs are expensive and must they be capitalised or not? These people are alcoholics who wrote this standard without clarity. 

Finally, if the shelf life is decreasing, you have spoilage treatment. Use JIT to order. There can be n school of thought bigger than this. 

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register  

Company
ARTICLESHIP 16 July 2026
Article Assistant

G A R U D & Associates

New Delhi

CA Inter

View Details
Company
20 July 2026
Senior GST Executive

Chandak Agarwal & Co

Mumbai

Graduate (Any)

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 28 July 2026
Article/Intern/Semi-Qualified/Fresher B.Com

VNSS & Co

Mumbai

Others

View Details
Company
21 July 2026
Chartered Accountant

Keshri & Associates

Thiruvananthapuram

CA

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 08 July 2026
Article internship

AJAY SINGH AND CO LLP

Thane

CA Final

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 16 July 2026
Article Assistant

Sahil Agarwal & Company

Mumbai

CA Inter

View Details
Company
11 July 2026
CA semi qualified

Vakilsearch.com

Chennai

CA Inter

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 15 July 2026
CA Articles

Kinjal H Shah & Co.

Mumbai

CA Foundation

View Details
Follow