About Nov 2008 exams

Final 2282 views 13 replies

CA. Harsh Jain

Audit & Taxation

118 Points Joined November 2008

The Accounts paper had a Printing Mistake in the Question of Value Added Statement, further, the short questions asked about IFRS,etc are not in Old Syllabus, its part of new syllabus. Plz comment.

The MAFA paper was so so lenghty, that it made the students leave atleast one question, the question of Portfolio Mgt. of 6 marks should atleast hv been of 12 marks.

In Audit Paper, 16 marks was asked from the SMC rule was asked, of which there is no mentioned in the leading reference books.

Only the law paper was the best and proper questions were asked.

Replies (13)

CA Jimmit D Mehta

Employed

494 Points Joined December 2008

ya i also heard abt it, but what we can do?

Praveen Kumar

CA Job

16 Points Joined April 2007

Whether Exam was easy or typical it all depends on ur performance

Yeh 180 minute ka khel hota hain jaani

Guest

441405 Points Joined August 2012

Dear Harsh,

I Can understand that the papers had questions from 'out-of-syllabus'. But, as CA Final students, where our level of knowledge (as given in syllabus of CA Final by ICAI) should be EXPERT KNOWLEDGE, how can u comlain about out-of-syllabus??? Expert knowledge meand knowing everything.

ISHA

103 Points Joined November 2008

yes u r right . i also faced the same problem but nothing was out of course it was from study mat of institute. n abt ifrs there was a ques in rtp of nov 2008

CA.Madhu

Charted Accountant

204 Points Joined December 2007

No problem, any way we performed well as we think, nobody can predict the result before it is announce, let us feel v perform well.

jeevana

Auditor

51 Points Joined July 2008

IFRS got very important in the present accounting and finance of every country.so Dept think that student must aware about present scenario about Finance and Accounts As CA so they give like that which not included in the old syllabue

jeevana

Auditor

51 Points Joined July 2008

i think CA got interested in taking of the interests and skills of students in general than book knowledge.so be well to get general knowledge equal to book knowledge

p kumar

assisstant

24 Points Joined September 2008

Dear friends

I too came to know that accounts paper was little bit tough.

But don't worry. Any one who has prepared well can get thorough.

RAHUL JAIN

student

74 Points Joined January 2009

Originally posted by :Jimmit Mehta
"	ya i also heard abt it, but what we can do?	"

even the paper of cost accounting of PE-II had a mistake as of which ancwer could not be found out. in the hindi version of paper things were different in that question

CA.JAYAKUMAR.J

Chartered accountant

308 Points Joined June 2008

yes thats true, but we cant do anything now , just wait n see

ALL THE BEST FOR EVERYBODY, LETS BE POSITIVE

CA. Rajeev Aggarwal

Chartered Accountant

3424 Points Joined October 2008

yes, no one can question.

just cross ur figners for results

jeevana

Auditor

51 Points Joined July 2008

IFRS is must for CA in order to get knowledge about accountine preparation

Deepak Sharma

JOB

27 Points Joined August 2008

Dear Sir/Madam

I Deepak sharma want to start the CA Study . I Passed My M.Com in 2005 so I want to know that what is the process of start the Program. Please tell me in detail. And I am regular member of CA Club India. Please Send the detail on my mail Id i.e deepak2re @ yahoo.co.in .Pleaseeeeeeeee.

Thanks

Deepak Sharma