A req to all seniors

Others 3046 views 33 replies

A req to all seniors …..

This message is dedicated to every person who possesses more knowledge then me,  because for me every such person is senior. So please read this carefully n hopefully u will follow the same.

 

It was 8 march2011. A day before tax exam. And I had already bookmarked one page to prepare for service tax and Vat, as I thought tht it wil b a source of revision. So focus on another subject for which exams r going rather than reading it all. While reading that I confronted that one q was in collusion with another answer. I thought It was mistake by chance, or may b I didn’t read it ..or I didn’t understand the meaning properly. So I jst gone through the link from where he picked it , It was his site. He is a Ca , and writer of almost 5 books on direct tax and investment. So I thought how can he be wrong ????? obviously m wrong …

I simply mailed my query to him. But this question was just not enough I found some more mistake there….. then I got  totally nervous. Like M wrong or his notes are wrong ??? this question was sauntering again n again in my mind. It was almost 2 hours reading this. Finally I confirmed the same thing with my 6 friends. They all confirmed the answer wrong…..!!!!!!!

 

So the consequences of all this are ……

·       He didn’t reply my answer even till now.______ so I just wanna say that if u r really not interested in answering the question about your own topic …then Y to give your ids, phone no ??

·       Be responsible _______ if u r a senior , then u must be responsible na. …… just because to earn some point or for publicity …..its not the way, that u can play with knowledge. Because other persons are relying upon u.

 

 

Lastly I got my friend’s words true ……

“Don’t download others notes which are given. They all are wrong”.

I really oppose him every time ….but now I found him totally true.

 

I m not here to criticize any one ….but please understand this thing …because I wasted my 5 hours upon this ….n every1 knows what 5 hours means in a exam day …SO please be responsible while sharing any notes ,….because may b u have covered the step …but other 1 is following your notes. Because yesterday I was here …tomorrow u can b in same situation.think about it deeply

Replies (33)

Very true...i also beleive in making my own notes.

well shared renu..

matter of seriousness to all responsible..

VERY WELL SAID . CAN YOU SEND THAT LINK HERE?

may be possible.

 

"Dikhawe pe na jao, apni akal lagao.
Hard Work hai Best, dont trust only on copy-paste "

Originally posted by : CA Ravi sisodia

may be possible.

 

"Dikhawe pe na jao, apni akal lagao.
Hard Work hai Best, dont trust only on copy-paste "
 

VERY WELL SAID SIR

i dont think i should share d same link .....

bt yes i can send u d wrong q 4 sure ...

Question

For certain taxable services rendered by Nidhi, VAT as well as service tax is leviable. The following bill was raised by Nidhi on Akanksha (service receiver) on 10-3-2010:

 

Particulars

Rs.

Amount of bill

50,000

VAT

400

Total

50,400

 

On 31-3-2010, Nidhi receives a sum of Rs. 40,000 in full settlement. What is the service tax payable? You are informed that Akanksha has incurred hotel bills of Rs. 5,150 on behalf of Nidhi. Clearly indicate the provisions considered in arriving at the service tax payable.

Answer

The value of taxable services is Rs. 50,000 plus consideration received in kind as per the valuation rules.

 

Service tax payable = Rs. 5,150

[Rs. (50,000 + 5,150) = Rs. 55,150 x 10.3/110.30

Take others as ur guide but dont bind yourself on the promises of person whom one neva know and dont know personally


still wish the best in the future 


Implied knowledge is power

yup thts all true ...bt whn we do self study v r unable to grasp each n every thing ......n its a usual presumption tht seniors r r8 ...

Originally posted by : *RENU*

yup thts all true ...bt whn we do self study v r unable to grasp each n every thing ......n its a usual presumption tht seniors r r8 ...

YES AGREE WITH YOU , BUT WE SHOULD NOT USE THAT MATERIAL DURING EXAMS. IT CREATES MORE CONFUSION. AND I WILL PERSONALLY REQUEST THE SENIORS PLZ. DONT PASTE SUCH COPY PASTE MATERIAL BEFORE PROPERLY ANALYSING IT.

Now i know why you were so tensed that day....

Very good point raised by. Incidence like these can spoil the career of a student. Please be sure before sharing any notes and students also sont follow any new notes if not studied earlier at the lats hours.

Whats the name of auther??

Hey chillax....!!!
aab kuch nai ho sakta...

The fact is even i came across few seniors too...

i actually had asked some queries a couple of days before exams abt tax to six of dem..but out of which only 2 had replied and d rest where really gr8 senior members on the boat hu dint reply even after my repetative humble requests...

later i had to go in exam hall carrying those doubts and praying dat  it shall never come and i was fortunate enuf but dat is not a long term perespective, so would try some ver else..:-(

Well all I can say is make ur own notes and don't use any new material especially on a day before ur exam.

Thats also my mistake ....i shouldnt use that material for exam day ... i agree wid it ...

n who all r saying ...it has passed ....

its nt passed until d mistakes r recovered ...


CCI Pro

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register