[URGENT]Will penalty be attracted?

464 views 1 replies

There is a sole-proprietorship concern where excisable goods are manufactured.

There was a routine audit  from Central Excise Department for years 2006 to 2010. Income tax audit had already been done for those years.

They found some goods which were  sold as free for sales promotion without payment of excise duty for year 2008-2009 and claimed Rs 72,000 as duty, Interest at 13% would be applicable. Now they are demanding that PENALTY would also be attracted @ 25% for every 30 days.

 

But these type of audits were done before too where they have paid only duty along with interest but NO PENALTY. So how come they demand penalty now with this audit? or are these officers just bluffing?

I would be greatful if learned professionals point me to the provisions and whether their claim for penalty is legal,

Replies (1)

Duty would be payable only if your clearance value (including free sample value) had exceeded Rs. 1.5 Crores. I am assuming that your turnover did exceed Rs. 1.5 Crores.

For penalty, there are two types of situations:

1. Where facts were suppressed with intention to evade duty: In cases of this type, penalty under Sec 11AC is imposable. The section says that if the duty, interest and penalty is paid within 30 days of adjudication, the penalty would be only 25% of the duty. Otherwise it would be 100% of the duty. [Remember, adjudication takes place after a Show Cause Notice is issued].

2. Where there was no suppression of facts with intention to evade, penalty cannot be imposed if the duty and interest is paid before issuance of notice. This is as per Sec 11A(2B).

I would suggest, you pay the duty and interest and send a written information that you were under belief that duty was not payable on free samples. Mention that you are filing the information under Sec 11A (2B) of the C. Excise Act, 1944. It may be that they do not issue the notice.

If a notice is issued alleging suppression of facts, you may contest it if you have suitable grounds. If on adjudication the penalty is confirmed, you can still pay 25% of the duty within 30 days of receipt of the adjudication order.

 


CCI Pro

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register