YOGESH MUNDHRA (B.COM (P) IPCC STUDENT) (79 Points)
08 August 2012ICAI ka kamal Dekho......... Kam marks but passed.
|
The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India |
ROLL Number |
310853 |
Name |
DIVYA VASUDEVA |
Group II |
|
Advanced Accounting |
044 |
Auditing and Assurance |
049 |
Information Technology and Strategic Management |
040 |
Total |
133 |
Result |
PASS |
Grand Total |
133 |
Deepak kumar sharma
(Govt. job)
(2946 Points)
Replied 08 August 2012
yes, this is a mistake. I don't know, is it technical or other? But according to rules of ICAI, she/he should be fail. This is really surprising.
suvobrata chatterjee
(Audit Assistant)
(31 Points)
Replied 09 August 2012
nothing wrong in this if the girl has passed her group 1 exam of ipcc with 217 marks out of 350marks( which is the passing total of both group together) then one can pass easily and logically. n
calculation>50% of 700( 7 papers)=350> is the minimum marks to pass ipcc both group. now one gets 133 marks in grp2 , then remaining marks (350-133)=217 marks has to be secured in group 1 to get an overall 50%. hai na Kamal ...!
suvobrata chatterjee
(Audit Assistant)
(31 Points)
Replied 09 August 2012
| Originally posted by : suvobrata chatterjee | ||
 |
nothing wrong in this if the girl has passed her group 1 exam of ipcc with 217 marks out of 350marks( which is the passing total of both group together) then one can pass easily and logically. n calculation>50% of 700( 7 papers)=350> is the minimum marks to pass ipcc both group. now one gets 133 marks in grp2 , then remaining marks (350-133)=217 marks has to be secured in group 1 to get an overall 50%. hai na Kamal ...! |
 |
suvobrata chatterjee
(Audit Assistant)
(31 Points)
Replied 09 August 2012
This is poosible only when one has alrady passed her grp1 with 217 marks or more.
Riyas cv
(CA Final, CS-Final)
(60 Points)
Replied 09 August 2012
| Originally posted by : suvobrata chatterjee | ||
|
|
This is poosible only when one has alrady passed her grp1 with 217 marks or more. |
|
dude, how its possible when one has done with 1st grp...??
suvobrata chatterjee
(Audit Assistant)
(31 Points)
Replied 09 August 2012
Dear Friend, Riyas, i could not foolow ur question but what i assume u want to say that what if i person has already passed 1st grp. Well my dear, the rule remains the same. first of all there can other side to it also. why people always jumps to premature conclusions, why r u so sure that its a mistake! did any one post the picture of the result of the previous attempts of the same girl. how can u judge without seeing both sides of the same coin. I am pretty sure that the girl must have passed her 1st grp in previous exam with more than at least 217 marks or more. now assuming she has already passed her 1st grp with 225 marks out of 400 marks total , nd in this attempt she gets 133 marks out of 300marks, then her aggregate in both groups comes to 358 marks which way beyond the minimum 350 marks. so she can pass in accordance to rule of ICAI." if a candidate secures 50% marks out of both group even if his/her minimum passing marks in one group is below the 50% mark, then the candidate shall be declared to be passed on the basis of total marks secured in both groups taken in aggregate.' please be updated about the new rules of Ipcc. i my shelf have passed IPCC by same way. i got 237 marks in group 1 and 141 marks in group 2. total 378 marks > 350 marks. Got it dude!!
suvobrata chatterjee
(Audit Assistant)
(31 Points)
Replied 09 August 2012
https://icai.org/new_post.html?post_id=8767&c_id=219
Plz watch this , u will get it. Dude!
Riyas cv
(CA Final, CS-Final)
(60 Points)
Replied 10 August 2012
Dear Suvobrata, i meant only if she hav had passed 1st grp in previous attempt, not in the same attempt..i know al rules brought by icai, infact im also coming by the way of ipcc same as carry forward rule..ok..anyhow dis girl got passed same as wat u said, ws correct, ie, 217+133. bcz it was a mistake frm icai, wich 1st grp result didnt come by mistake..by the way,i surrendered, u r realy intelligent, obviously eligible to become CA..happy dude..??..:):)
CA Vikas Kumar Sharma
(CA)
(494 Points)
Replied 11 August 2012
sheetal pande
(4 Points)
Replied 11 November 2018
sheetal pande
(4 Points)
Replied 11 November 2018
CAclubindia
