LIVE GST Certification Course by CA Arun Chhajer begins 21st April. Register Now!!

Yogendra Bangar for Direct Taxes

(Guest)

I bought for ca final old syllabus direct taxes exam...yogendra bangar's book and his compiler(aadhyas)

Is it ok? Some of my friends ask me to return this book and get tn manoharan or vk singhania or ahuja or vinod gupta.

But the seller is not willing to take back the book,so am stuck with this book...

personally i dont see anything wrong with the book.

but is it enough if i work with this book...if anyone has passed with this book,please reply to this posting....

i know bangar is for indirect taxes...but i find even this book to be good..please help me...im giving this may 2010 old syllabus ca final....i have not made much head way into this subjectthe subject direct taxes frightens me....please help me...

Reply
Follow
Share

19 Replies

Ratan Deep Saxena (Asstt Manager (Accounts & Finance)) (2998 Points)
Replied 20 February 2010

Dear Neha,

Though i hd nt studied bangar for direct taxes, bt still u stick with this book and plz don't get confused with wat ur friend says coz every book contains the best matter in itself.

So go with it..........

Happy reading..........

Best of Luck........

regards,

ratan

(Guest)

please help me...i need replies and discussions on this please....i dont have much time for may 2010...im really afraid...

(Guest)

thanks ratan but i need someone who has read this book and cleared the paper to tell me and give me confidence....bahut dar gayi jab suna ki yeh book kaafi nahin hain....

Ratan Deep Saxena (Asstt Manager (Accounts & Finance)) (2998 Points)
Replied 20 February 2010

u shud concentrate on ur studies as per views.... I hv nt taken any coachings for finals and i ws told by my friends that u were nt able to clear any of ur groups without any coachings. Bt still ws able to clear my 1 gr & exemption in MICS. To kya mujhe bhi daar jana chahiye tha. Ppl may afraid u..... u shud maintain your confidence rather seeking any person who studied that book.

regards,

ratan

CA Rachit K Patel (Chartered Accountant) (1503 Points)
Replied 20 February 2010

Hi Neha,

I had scored 63 in direct tax by reading manoharan.During that time even my friend has suggested me to go for ahuja or singhania.But dear fimally its upto us how we make the praearation.It doesn't make much difference whether you read yogesh bangar or manoharan or any other authors book.And finally remove the fear from your heart & mind just do your studies well.

All the best.

Rachit K Patel

Sanjay M (FM) (38 Points)
Replied 20 February 2010

Hi Guys..

Ratan you are 100% right..either of books mentioned by Neha won'g gaurantee that you student will clear the exams.. i think whats imp is the concepts should be clear..and if we concentrate on studies and not what stupid people say about Authors who write books..we can surely clear the exams..so Neha cheer up..and concentrate on your studies..only failures blaim on books................all da best...

Raghav Gupta (CA Final & CS Executive Student) (212 Points)
Replied 20 February 2010

neha bangar sir book is good from exam point of view, many of my friends have cleared their exam refering the same, so dont get confused and carry on with the same book..

All the best.......

1 Like

shinoj (ab) (1201 Points)
Replied 20 February 2010

dear neha,

book does not matter at all but focus and attitute towards studies matter..no doubt for indirect tax paper bangar is the best..but for direc tax too it is good enough..vinod gupta's module is too heavy n it is challenging to finsih everything..first pick important topics from bangar and prepare.. then later go for all topics at least for once..concepts should be clear ..

(Guest)

Originally posted by : Raghav Gupta
	neha bangar sir book is good from exam point of view, many of my friends have cleared their exam refering the same, so dont get confused and carry on with the same book.. All the best.......

Thankyou Raghav this is the authentic confirmation i needed...

I also thank ratan and others who have encouraged me...

I will follow bangar then for direct taxes too...

I actually thought it was an easier book to finish than the rest in the market also all itats and caselaws are given in one place and what is needed in for the syllabus...but jsut that my friends frightened me that it is meant for new syllabus not old syllabus so dar gayi thoda sa...

Thanks everyone...best of luck for exams every1

(Guest)

Originally posted by : CA Rachit K Patel
	Hi Neha, I had scored 63 in direct tax by reading manoharan.During that time even my friend has suggested me to go for ahuja or singhania.But dear fimally its upto us how we make the praearation.It doesn't make much difference whether you read yogesh bangar or manoharan or any other authors book.And finally remove the fear from your heart & mind just do your studies well. All the best. Rachit K Patel

Thankyou Rachit,your story was inspirational...

Vivek (Finally passed CA Final...!!!!!) (1097 Points)
Replied 20 February 2010

Yogendra bangar Book is also good... Actually, DT was a nightmare for me in all my 3 attempts... In my third attempt, I failed because of Dt only... I got only 31... Had i scored 40, i would have passed... In All those attepmts, i referred TN manoharan... In my 4th attempt, i bought Bangar (Both book & compilation) & i scored 46... Not a good score... but better than my previous attempts.... & i cleared my CA exams...

Note: I Dont say TN Manoharan Book is not good.... He is a great author.... But i say that, Bangar book is also good......

CA Arif A. Dadani (Chartered Accountant) (68 Points)
Replied 20 February 2010

tht book of bangar is good i scored 57 with tht book so i say dat book is good.

ca manoj rathi (ca) (152 Points)
Replied 20 February 2010

hi...

i hav stdied 2 times n given attempt...

it is good for getiing 45-55 marks...

bt if u wish more thn must opt other book thnn bangar

shinoj (ab) (1201 Points)
Replied 20 February 2010

Originally posted by : manoj rathi
	hi... i hav stdied 2 times n given attempt... it is good for getiing 45-55 marks... bt if u wish more thn must opt other book thnn bangar

not agree with rathi coz there's nothing anything special contain in vinod gupta module or singhania or so..emphasis on concepts u may win gold medal by just following book of bangar's only.don't belive others..don't bet on authors..bet on concepts n clarity of expressions..