Tax Professional and in Service
1795 Points
Joined June 2009
Good Question Rajkumar,
If you are claiming status to be as non resident because of your residence in nepal/Bhutan, you must have the valid proof to substantiate your claim. There was one case law passed in favour of revenue which exactly matches with details you mentioned. It was held that
"Only because there is open border between India and Nepal and as Passport is not required to travel to and from between India and Nepal, it cannot be presumed that anyone who claims to be Indian national residing in Nepal, is a non-resident Indian. Simply because it is difficult to prove in such a case whether a person was residing for a particular period in Nepal or in India, it does not mean that the claim of a person who claims to be residing in Nepal that he is a non-resident Indian, has to be accepted by the authorities."
So even if resident claimed as non residence just because his stay in Nepal, Income Tax department has the authority to go into the details as its a pure question of facts and not the question of law.
So if you want to get inside the umbrella of Non resident, you better should have the valid proofs for substantiation. Better you can carry passport and get it stamped for the date or hotel bills for stay in Nepal or some other valid proof to substantiate your stay in Nepal/bhutan.
Enclosed herewith High Court of Rajasthan, Jaipur bench citation for your reference.
Thanks and Regards,
Manoj B. Gavali