why result of 2nd group is less than the 1st (PCC)

Final 1928 views 16 replies

Exam
MM/YYYY
Course
Group I
Group II
Both Group
Appeared
Passed
Pass %
Appeared
Passed
Pass %
Appeared
Passed
Pass %
May 2008
Final
17552
6444
36.71
18685
5290
28.31
10580
2645
25
PCE
2320
857
36.94
2351
494
21.01
1948
436
22.35
PE-II
23721
4026
16.97
27209
5591
20.55
17341
1384
7.98
November 2007
Final
16137
6353
39.37
16493
5005
30.35
8654
2446
28.26
PCE
137
34
24.82
130
06
4.62
85
05
5.88
PE-II
34766
8737
25.13
39267
8743
22.27
25671
3433
13.37
May 2007
Final
15083
2289
15.18
15874
2777
17.49
7467
1023
13.70
PCE
38
09
23.68
34
03
8.82
21
02
9.52
PE-II
42991
12909
30.03
44496
10668
23.98
30863
5872
19.03
November 2006
Final
14587
5505
37.74
16947
6555
38.68
6830
1830
26.79
PE-II
35653
12214
34.26
37229
11960
32.13
23662
5658
23.91
May 2006
Final
15355
5832
37.98
17952
5718
31.85
7053
1608
22.80
PE-II
34872
10954
31.41
37288
14132
37.9
22655
5773
25.48
November 2005
Final
15902
5039
31.68
20085
5772
28.74
7620
1348
17.69
PE-II
31420
9098
28.96
36512
12131
33.22
20410
4216
20.66
May 2005
Final
18211
5748
31.56
20513
3520
17.16
8650
1243
14.37
PE-II
32753
8656
26.43
37641
8653
22.99
21068
2664
12.64
November 2004
Final
16645
4089
24.57
20448
4484
21.93
7666
939
12.25
PE-II
33809
7378
21.82
39659
6863
17.31
22411
2307
10.29
May 2004
Final
20724
7011
33.83
21364
3354
15.70
9770
1490
15.25
PE-II
34429
7478
21.72
39603
8186
20.67
21244
2392
11.26
November 2003
Final
19501
4450
22.82
20377
4381
21.50
8597
1076
12.52
PE-II
32941
6182
18.77
38760
6329
16.33
20248
2107
10.41
May 2003
Final
20290
4469
22.03
18692
2203
11.79
7943
802
10.10
PE-II
29057
5524
19.01
32857
4614
14.04
14756
1208
8.19
 

Replies (16)

please share the reason of that so that it may help the student to work on it.............

The reason is that TAX gets extreme results.... Either exemptions are there or expectetions are broken very badly......

 

The second reason is IT.... this subject is never understood, rather only ruttofied by the students.., so thats something hindering at large scale....

 

is there any other reason also other than above ??? ICAI??

I think ICAI too acts partial regarding this issue...

 

But Q is why it will do so?? I mean, why they'll partial to one group only???

 

 i think only ICAI can tell this......

hahaaa...

 

No, but if we seriosly think, then it cannot be ICAI only or the part of ICAI's partiallity in such result won't have great proportion.... Its the subjects that are responsible for lower result

(Its the subjects that are responsible for lower result)

 

what it means that the subject in 2nd group are difficult or marking level is low

No no... niehter the subjects are difficult nor are the marking levels....

 

But as i said, its the complication in mind of srudents that becomes hinderance... The subjects are easy, but students do make conceptual mistakes in TAX.... For IT too, its not tough, its not lengthy, but the language there is complicated...

in my opinion It is not the reason whether any subject is easy or hard.

DT is the main subject for a CA. He should have an expert knowledge about it.

that is the reason why institute make marking of DT low.

Sometimes an easy paper of DT could not give a better result as compared to other subjects.

i think institute flactuate result of II group according to market demand of CA..

ok thanks dhiraj  & atul for sharing ur valuable time on this........

once again thanks a lot

I think expertise required in Gr 2 is nery high.Take DT IDT and Cost.

In cost if you are not able to complete the paper then u r gone. In DT If you hav not studied case laws and in IDT i dont see ay author who has complete coverage of course.

I FELT THAT TAX & IT R THE MOST EASY SUBJECT WHERE U CAN EASILY SEURE ABOVE 50 MARKS EASILY.....AS PER ME........I HAVE A PROBLEM WITH COSTING PAPER AS IT WAS LENGHTY TO SOLVE WITHIN THE GIVEN TIME PERIOD.........

its all due to I.T S.M

i think so

I think the main reason behind this that cost FM IT SM, as all subjests are of 50 marks. .......and have lengthy too........& also depends on ICAI........


CCI Pro

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register