YOU MAY BUY VASHIST AND SAXENA OR PADHUKAS. I DO NOT KNOW THE NAME OF THE BOOK WHICH U SAID.

Ashish Kalra books are rated as very good books for ca.

PADHUKA  IS THE ONE OF THE BEST BOOK FOR COSTING ....................

I gree with mitu prefer to refer PADHUKA BOOK SARVANA PRASHATH

Dear anchal ! you should concentrare on module and past exams questions first then u can go for other refrence books . if you go through module and scanner only then also u can get exemption marks.  its more than sufficient .
 

Originally posted by : anchal abhinandan
	Someone pls tell me how is the book of Ashish Kalra, Should I buy that....for costing IPcc.......pls suggest me as early as possible.......

You Can purchase it from ITO ( Pooja / Aggarwal Law Hose)  or contact  'IGP Councellor'   @ 9250430788 or  01141576333. She will let u know from where you can get it ..

a big yes 4 kalra sir's book . it's lengthy and try all questions 2 be achiever

Ashish Kalra book is very good book but all books cover all examination point or que . do hard work all the best

kalra sir'book is good  but do compiler also all the best

Ashish karla book is good ...cos there is vast range of questions and solutions given (u will get all types) and there are questions given for practice also with answers .But i think for concepts and clarity u will have to refer some other books.....Ashish Karla is good to get an idea of the types .....mujhe toh aisa hi laga......moreover i found the font size too small....very difficult to read the text (mayb bcos i wear specs)....and concepts not very clearly given...so conclusion is that-----"its very good for practise"

Dear anchal ! you should concentrare on module and past exams questions first then u can go for other refrence books . if you go through module and scanner only then also u can get exemption marks.  its more than sufficient

Agree With Shubham...

Thanks everyone for ur valuable suggestion........I have decided not to buy any book I have saxena vashist and compilation also I will refer that and try from that..........special thanx to Akshay pal.........

I THINK IF YOU HAVE  DONE CLASSES THEN FIRST DO COMPLETE THAT THEN U CAN GO FOR COMPILATION AND MODULE  PROBLEMS

AND CHAPTERWISE U CAN GO THROUGH THE BOOK WHICHEVER SUGGESTED BY OTHERS.

BUT MY PERSONEL RECOMENDATION IS  GO THROUGH WITH THE CLASSES BOOKS PLUS COMPILATION