LIVE GST Certification Course by CA Arun Chhajer begins 21st April. Register Now!!

THE NEGLECTED : PE-II

AJAY DAGAR (Member of CA club INDIA) (198 Points)

04 September 2009

Just 0.25% manage to clear the exam. Can it be possible that all others did not prepare at all?????????????????????? at that time all PE-II students knew that it was their last attempt so I think everyone must have prepared well............they knew it was their last chance

Reply
Follow
Share

14 Replies

Sachin Sawrikar (CA (final) & CS (final) yr student) (40 Points)
Replied 04 September 2009

Ya, but ICAI wants to reduce results this time. No matter how much we have studied, the result is declared and thats all. Results were intentionally reduced but we cant do anything, ICAI is like god for ca student, we cant go against it. Thats the truth.

Pradip Srinivasan (CA Final) (869 Points)
Replied 04 September 2009

S, the intention of the institute is to show low results. So whether hardworked or not has no role to play there.

0.25% Is not tolerable, for this the exam could have not kept.

suresh (service) (151 Points)
Replied 04 September 2009

CIC decided, CA student to get copy of answer sheet under RTI Act

Decision No.4167/IC(A)/2009 , F. No.CIC/MA/A/2009/000474 , Dated, the 13^thJuly, 2009 , Delivered by : Central Information Commission.

MOHSIN CHIKANI (Senior Accountant) (28 Points)
Replied 04 September 2009

Dear Suresh & all other troubled PE- 2 students,

First of all 0.25% is certainly not an acceptable result. I have discussed this matter with several professors of coaching classes & they say that one should compel the institute to provide copies of evaluated answer sheets under the RTI Act. If anyone of you knows the procedure for application under the RTI act please let me know the same. Secondly there is no such thing which makes the ICAI or for that matter the president of ICAI feel that they are GOD & cannot be challenged. Dear Freinds let us all stand united & act fast. In fact I would like to put this as an appeal to All India CA students to stand united & boycot these results & compel the institute for a fresh & fair evaluation .

Bhavik Davda (Proprietor) (238 Points)
Replied 04 September 2009

Dear friends...i have left to clear my second grop of P.E. II really... i cant understand where i am lacking..... i have given my 100% but the result is the lowest till the date....Really friends we need to take a serious steps for this un predictable results

Jamila Karori (Manager Audit & Compliance) (107 Points)
Replied 04 September 2009

Yes, Bhavik you are right , we need to take really serious steps , now if such trend of low passouts continue we should really ork very hard just to clear.

Ajay (Accountant) (72 Points)
Replied 04 September 2009

Ya you allright

I think institute required fund for this recession

they newer check our paper they just taking paper like stock market

anyway guies forget thik what happen we have to prove our professional approcj for next atten

all the best

Rajesh.S (Student) (54 Points)
Replied 04 September 2009

Friends lets us not jump in to conclusions by seeing the number 0.25%.The institute has already extended this syallabus more than two times previously.To be in the positive side the intention would be to give the candiates more chance for clearing the exams.In this background there is very lesser chance on the part of institute to announce a low result.Answers for all our questions will be known only when we are allowed to see our answer papers under RTI Act.If this low result was intentional then serious remedies are needed to protect the students carrier.

jayant sahu (student ) (26 Points)
Replied 04 September 2009

hello guys pe 2 it is again god this cant happen ...

dont know wat has led to such situation tat they have to withheld

students marks ...in any normal correction wat we experienced

i shud have got at any cost 159 ,, i m left wid second grp only

the marks i secured is 43 45 46 ohh god ...

brain juggler it is ..

but just wanna see wer i did mistakes in my expectations ..

jayant sahu (student ) (26 Points)
Replied 04 September 2009

plzz plzzz plzzz

is any1 hearing my cry tell me the procedure for getting the zerox copy

of my papers under RTI act as i have heard n seen the post....

anyway i m ready to work even harder n come out of 160 zone ..

god willing will prepare so hard tat they wont dare reduce the marks ..

All d best to other pe2 guys who have failed..

plz tell me soon wats the procedure to secure zerox copy..

or else shall i start it again soon plz time is short

thnx

CA Sumit Tayal (Chartered Accountant) (158 Points)
Replied 04 September 2009

YES

YOU ARE RIGHT

Shekhar (CA & CS) (72 Points)
Replied 04 September 2009

All the guys who want photo copies of their evaluated answer sheets... GET THIS CLEAR...

Our institute does not provide for any such thing... but as most of you'll have read in various articles that RTI certainly does...

Now there could be two ways to get there...

Either stick to your stand and be hell bent to get back your evaluated copies (which i certainly doubt is a very lengthy process)

Work towards clearing the next attempt. - THE CHOICE IS YOURS!!!

Shekhar (CA & CS) (72 Points)
Replied 05 September 2009

And look guys... we can we do one thing...

Those who are certain to give November 2009 attempt... We all can assemble together online, become friends, help out each other in all queries...difficulties, support each other in this hour of emotional and mental distress.

So I invite you all PE2 students to come forward and join me on yahoo, where we can chat and comfort eachother. My email id is shekhar979 @ yahoo.com. Send me an invite on yahoo messenger with a little info about urself and we all can then know eachother.

Take care guys... BYE

AJAY DAGAR (Member of CA club INDIA) (198 Points)
Replied 05 September 2009

ICAI has left us confused : whether to go for exam in this november or leave CA and do something else or enter the job market.

I think ICAI must suggest some solution regarding career of those who cannot afford studying now and needs job.............no guarantee whether this result will be repeated again...........................

I think it is time to decide as running after one thing madly does not make sense for those who need job