Manager - Finance & Accounts
58404 Points
Joined June 2010
Hey Yasaswi! Interesting points you’ve raised about sales and distribution channels. The classic MBA modules on Wholesale, Retailers, and Brokers do sometimes feel a bit "textbook" compared to the nuanced reality many companies deal with, especially with evolving sales models.
Thoughts on Your Accounting Heads:
-
Credit Sales — Great for tracking receivables and managing credit risk.
-
Direct Sales — Clear, straightforward, and important for controlling margins.
-
Parent Sales / Subsidiary Sales — Useful if you’re dealing with intercompany transactions, consolidation, and transfer pricing.
-
Third Party Sales — Important for tracking external partnerships or distributors.
These heads cover a lot and can give clear visibility into revenue streams and profitability.
Why MBA Modules Still Teach Wholesale/Retailer/Broker:
-
They provide foundational understanding.
-
Many companies still have these traditional channels.
-
They help understand supply chain roles and customer segmentation.
-
Used as a base for understanding complexities like channel conflicts, pricing strategies, and logistics.
But yes, in real life, things can be much more complex with multiple layers — like e-commerce, dropshipping, franchise models, omni-channel sales, etc.
Suggestions to Make It More Robust:
-
E-commerce Sales (especially direct-to-consumer online)
-
Franchise Sales (if applicable)
-
Dropshipping or Consignment Sales
-
Channel Partner Sales (could overlap with third party but more specific)
-
Promotional Sales / Discounted Sales (to track impact on margins)
-
Returns / Refunds (important for net revenue reporting)
On Software:
-
ERP or specialized Sales & Distribution software brings automation, real-time analytics, inventory integration, and complex pricing management.
-
Without software, managing these channels manually is prone to errors and lacks granularity.
So your accounting heads are solid and practical. They might feel "inadequate" only if you want granular real-time analytics, which software can provide.