Salary Taxable Perquisite - Sale of Asset and Use of Asset

Analysis of  Classification of the Asset The television will be classified under the head "Other assets" for perquisite purposes, as it is not a computer or a motor car.

Taxable Amount The taxable amount will be the difference between the original cost of the television (₹60,000) and the amount charged from the employee (₹44,000), which is ₹16,000.

Depreciation Treatment Since the asset was sold to the employee, the employer will not be able to claim depreciation on the asset. Time Period for Taxable Amount The taxable amount will be considered for the period the asset was in use by the employee, which is from May 1, 2024, to November 30, 2024. 

The taxable amount will not be divided over the full year, but rather considered for the specific period of usage.

Perquisite Value The total value of the perquisite will be ₹16,000, which is the difference between the original cost and the amount charged from the employee.

1.The televsion will be classified under other assets, correct.

2. time period for usage of asset will be the time asset was used, correct.

3. total Taxable value of perq is incorrect.

4. Correct answer: Since the question comprises of two parts

i. use of asset,

ii. sale of asset

i. Taxable perq for use of asset

= (1.5.24 to 30.11.24) - 10% of Actual cost of asset*No.of days used
=0.1*60000*7/12
=3500

ii. Taxable perq for sale of asset = 10% SLM 

Original cost = 60000

less :

year1 depn = Purchase to year end = (15.12.23 to 31.3.24) = NIL (since less than year, depn will be NIL)
year 2 depn= year start till asset sold = (1.4.24 to 30.11.24) = NIL (since less than year, depn willbe NIL)
WDV=60000
(10% of 60000 = 6000)

i+ii = (6000+3500=19500)

(depn for use of asset is specifically stated that if asse is used for less than a year NIL depn, if it is used more than 1year, depn will be 1yr)

This was the major ambiguity.

Two perquisites, valued under Rule 3(7):

1. Use of the TV, 1 May 2024 to 30 November 2024: use of movable assets (other than cars, laptops or computers) is valued at 10% per annum of the original cost, pro rata (Rule 3(7)(vii)). For 7 months: 60,000 × 10% × 7/12 = Rs 3,500 (less any amount recovered from the employee).

2. Transfer to the employee on 30 November 2024: Rule 3(7)(viii). For assets other than computers, electronic items and cars, value = actual cost less 10% depreciation for each completed year of use by the employer, less the amount recovered. The TV was used for less than one completed year, so no depreciation: perquisite = Rs 60,000 (if nothing paid). If you treat the TV as an "electronic item" (the Rule's term covers data storage and handling devices, which TVs generally aren't), 50% WDV per completed year applies, again nil for under a year.

• Total perquisite: about Rs 63,500, taxed as salary through Form 16 (both regimes).

• If the employee pays a fair price, the perquisite reduces accordingly.

A television is an “other asset” for Rule 3(7)(v) of the Income-tax Rules—not a computer or motor car. For use of an employer-owned asset, the taxable value is 10% p.a. of the asset’s actual cost, for the period it was used, reduced by any amount recovered from the employee for that use. On transfer, the value is actual cost less depreciation at 10% for each completed year of use, reduced by the sale price charged to the employee.

Here, use from 1 May to 30 November 2024 is seven months. Use value: ₹60,000 × 10% × 7/12 = ₹3,500. The television had not completed a year of use when transferred, so no depreciation is deducted for the transfer valuation; taxable transfer value is ₹60,000 − ₹44,000 = ₹16,000. Total perquisite: ₹19,500, assuming no separate charge was recovered for the period of use. The purchase date alone does not create a completed year of use; the relevant period is the period the employer-owned asset was used.

This treatment can be reflected in the payroll perquisite computation and supporting records for the relevant months. Manual tracking of asset use, recovery and depreciation is difficult, while automation reduces repetitive work and keeps professional judgment in control. At Jir AI we provide 2,000+ AI agents and 650+ integrations to streamline your practice’s day-to-day workload. For a practical workflow discussion, connect with us on WhatsApp: https://wa.me/message/3HVOZ7HIY4ESC1