Now i know why ICAI give 3.5% CA Final result!

3645 views 49 replies

CA Anuj

Chartered Accountant

230 Points Joined July 2008

The CFA (usa) gives pass percent of 53%. CIMA (uk) gives pass percent of more than 50%. ICAI is not more popular than these prestigeous institutes of global acclaim.

Then why so low percentage.

The possible reasons, as discussed in forums, are:

1. To earn more money by stucking the students in the system.

2. Because the campus has proved a big failure in recent times. And there is no logic of passing more CAs when the existing one are jobless.

3. To teach a lesson to coaching centers by killing students.

But, one thing that has crossed my mind is:

The ICAI people, those who have cleared the exam when the pass percent was 20% or more, wants to show the world that they are better than CPA of CFA as the course in India much harder to pass.

To raise their value in the global markets they are doing these stunts.

Your views!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Replies (49)

Guest

TOTALLY AGREE WITH ANUJ

Surya Jain

Student

944 Points Joined October 2008

TOTALLY DISAGREE!!

Where are you leaving, today there is a lot of demand for CA, if you are a CA you can negotiate for the salary like anything, if you are a CA you need not even have to be jobless for even 1 day, Have you ever analysied that why people fail in CA, it just because that they take it as Degree exam, And let me tell you one more thing that CFA, CPA is more harder then CA, you try & give exam for CFA/CPA, if you pass in that then you say that, CA is bad, without knowing every kind of fact, we should not come to any kind of conclusion, and if you really think that its bad, then why are you here in CA, do something else, or I will suggest you to not to do anything, that will only be better for you, atleast you will not say anything wrong for anything!!

you ask to any professional, he will totally disagree with you.

If you felt bad then I am sorry but just wanted to tell the fact, there is so many things which I can explain you,but if you want to understand then much is enough.

Darshan

Manager

53 Points Joined October 2009

@ Surya.

Boss !! can u answer

1. If we are takin CA as degree examinations then ask your ICAI president to show the evalutaed papers so that the independent experts decide our answers quality..Can you ??

2. Who said CPA is tough than CA ?? My friend attempted CA inter thrice and not cleared , he left the course and completed CPA.. And now its a recent strategy by intelligent people to do CPA rather than doing CA .. Have you wrote CPA/CFA anytime ??

3. Lets have a mock CA test..Ask someone who is very professional , it can be even your ICAI president - to attend the test and lets see whether he could clear with pass standards..

It is clearly eveident the ICAI should be doing all these for one or more reasons below

1. Money

2. To Enjoy the course Credibility

3.Just to show off to global professional courses to attract attention.

4.Enjoy the Articles sweat for long time for cheap labour.

5.Insane Administ Team

6.Old Jaw shaking members are scared about todays young genereation tech savvy and intelligent candidates might take the profession in thier hand, leaving behind rusted clients to them..

If you felt bad then I am sorry but just wanted to tell the fact, there is so many things which I can explain you,but if you want to understand then much is enough.

CA. Harsh Arora

Chartered Accountant

377 Points Joined February 2009

HA HA HA.....Thanks sudarsan for giving the answer to someone who even dont know what he is saying!

Guest

You all don't have any work or what???? Simply criticising... Either change what you feel is wrong or keep your mouth shut, if you can't do anything. There are more better things to do. One fellow i have observed named Jose.P. , he always open his shop for criticising ICAI. All his points are for that only. Everywhere he will open his mouth against ICAI(i mean in some kargil forum also). Sadly, he is just wasting time and has not done anything to change.

Personally i don't have any problem with ICAI. You all have problem because you are trying to shift your blame.Accept it or change.

@ Sudarsan,

If you want to see your copy get it through RTI. ICAI will not make the rule for seeing answer copy. It will lead to lakhs of request to see their copy, leading to waste of time and unnecessary process will come up. All the copies are evaluated at a very high benchmark . If you feel any wrong is done to you, get it through RTI. Hope then you will be satisfied to know your worth in CA(demands quality and not stale vegetables)

Dheeraj

Learner

1100 Points Joined February 2009

ICAI is just playing Games with Students' life if they don't want to invite more CA's in market, than why they are promoting the students in INTER or CPT

Guest

@ sudarsan,

You say all things are for money only.. ok fine tell me???

You enjoy such a beautiful infrastructure , how it comes???

You get free access to virtual classes. how it comes???

You get free access to latest mateials on website(Don't say materials are not updated, have you ever read ??? There are so many sources to learn like journals, amendments book) How it comes???

Have you ever enjoyed in ITT labs sitting in A/c... How it comes??

Have you ever appreciated charity work done by ICAI????

Have you ever visited ARF of ICAI???? from where money comes to carry out research????

list goes on.....

ICAI is not doing it for themselves... If students are failing by not studying properly.. Is ICAI to be blamed????

Guest

Originally posted by : Dheeraj
	ICAI is just playing Games with Students' life if they don't want to invite more CA's in market, than why they are promoting the students in INTER or CPT

No.. Its you who is not aware of knack to qualify CA or you are not doing/studying as per professional approach of CA. Don't play with CA course by studying like B.com/BBA

Guest

Originally posted by : Dheeraj
	ICAI is just playing Games with Students' life if they don't want to invite more CA's in market, than why they are promoting the students in INTER or CPT

I have never seen rankholders cribbing like this against ICAI .... Hope you all got my answer

$AcH!n G

Still Running for My Destination

1036 Points Joined April 2008

I'm agree with SUDARSAN. lower passing %age of CA EXAMS does not shows we don't have knowledge.

even we have knowledge more than passing one's. now whatever the reason for lower passing % age of CA EXAMS but reality is that ICAI is not passing the students because ICAI wants expert knowledge and we don't know what is the meaning of " expert knowledge " for ICAI.So that we can fulfill their requirements.

Guest

Originally posted by : $AcH!n G
	I'm agree with SUDARSAN. lower passing %age of CA EXAMS does not shows we don't have knowledge. even we have knowledge more than passing one's. now whatever the reason for lower passing % age of CA EXAMS but reality is that ICAI is not passing the students because ICAI wants expert knowledge and we don't know what is the meaning of " expert knowledge " for ICAI.So that we can fulfill their requirements.

Correct, you accepted that you are not an expert and that is why student like you fall in that 97% category. Better study in an excellent manner. Become ruthless in studying and not ruthless in passing comments. Everything will be fine and you will succeed surely. Study like a rank holder