My articleship experience...

Articleship 3520 views 23 replies

 


HI I AM A STUDENT OF CA FINAL AND I COMPLETED MY PE 2 IN NOV'06. THEREAFTER I JOINED A CA FIRM ON 15/02/07.ON 30/9/07 I LEFT IT . REASONS OF LEAVING:


1. WHEN MY CA COMES TO HIS OFFICE HIS WIFE TOLD ME TO HELP SIR TO BRING HIS BAGS AND THEREFORE I GO OUT OF OFFICE WHERE THE CAR IS BEING PARKED BY SIR AND TOLD ME TO CARRY LAPTOPS, MAYUR JUG IN, WHICH WATER IS KEPT, AND HIS BASKET WHERE HE KEPT HIS FOOD OR FRUITS. IT TAKES ME 5 MIN FOR ME CARRY ALL THESE TO OFFICE AS THE OFFICE IS SITUATED A BIT FAR AWAY AND MY CA WALK WITHOUT CARRYING ANTTHING IN FRONT OF ME AS HE WANT TO SHOW TO OUTSIDE PUBLIC. (DAILY WORK)


2. SERVING MY CA WITH WATER WHEN HE WANTS EVEN WHEN IS KEPT NEAR HIM OR ON HIS DESK & BRINGING TEA FROM OUTSIDE IN OR PLASTIC BAGS OR IN ANY OTHER COMPONENT WHEN HE WANTS TEA OUT OF MY OWN MONEY.(DAILY WORK)


3. WHEN CLIENTS COME TO MEET THE SAME WORK IS DONE.


4. ONE DAY HE TOLD ME TO THAT I HAVE TO COME WITH A CLIENT IN SAKET. ON REACING THE TOWER WHERE OFFICE IS SITUATED HE TOLD ME CARRY MY OWN BAG AND LAPTOP OF SIR AND MY CA IS CARRYING A DIARY AND I AM WALKING BEHIND HIM AS IF HE WANTS TO SHOW SOMTHING TO OFFICE STAFF THAT WHAT HE IS AND I AM HIS SERVANT AND TOLD ME TO STAND OUTSIDE THE OFFICE OF HIS CLIENT BUT ATLEAST HIS CLIENT HAS SOME MANNERS AND HE TOLD ME ALSO TO COME IN AND HAVE A SEAT AND AFTER THE MEETING IS OVER HE TOLD ME TO GO OFFICE AS NOW YOUR WORK IS FINISHED.


5. WHEN MY CA WANTS TO EAT SOMETHING THEY TOLD TO BRING NAAN , SAMOSA FOR HIM TO EAT OUT MY OWN PERSONAL MONEY (ROUTINE WORK)


6. THEIR IS AN NGO WHERE I HAVE TO WORK TO MAINTAIN THE ACCOUNTS OF NGO 3 DAYS A WEEK THEIR ALSO SAME WORKS ARE BEING DONE IN THE OFFICE LIKE MERE LIYE PAANI LE AAOO, CHAII LE AAYO, GAADI ME MERA KHANA PADA HO GA WOH LE AAYO, MERE LIYE FRUITS LEAAYO BAHAR JA KE , MERE LIYE NAAN LE AAYO . (ROUTINE WORK)


7. ONE DAY HE TOLD ME AT 6 PM TO COME WITH ME TO MEET SOMEONE AND GO WITH HIM IN HIS CAR HE TAKE ME TO SOME SHOP AND TOLD ME TO CARRY THE 20 LTRS WATERS BAGS (2 PCS) AND THE EQUIPMENT THAT HAS TO BE ATTACHED WITH IT IN THE OFFICE I CARRY 1 BAG ON MY SHOULDER AND OTHER BY THE SERVANT IN THE SHOP AND EQUIPMENT BY BOTH OF US IE ME AND SERVANT TO PUT THEM IN THE CAR AND WHEN I SAID SIR NOW SHOULD I GO HE TOLD ME TUMNE HI TOH ISSE UTHAKAR OFFICE ME RAKHNA HAI AND THE WAY BEHAVED WITH ME IN THE CAR CANNOT BE EXPRESSED IN WORDS AND THEN I HAVE PUT THE BAGS ON MY SHOULDER AND PUT THEM IN THE OFFICE.


8. DEPOSITING CHEQUES OF SIR IN THE BANK, TELEPHONE BILLS , ELECTRICITY BILLS.(ROUTINE WORK)


9. ONE DAY HE TOLD ME TO BRING PACKET OF SIGRETS FOR THE CLIENTS AND MANY TIMES HE HAS TOLD ME TO GIVE ASHTRAY TO THE CLIENTS SMOKIMG SIGRATTES IN THE OFFICE.


10. SIR WANTS TO EAT MANGO THEREFORE THEY TOLD ME TO WASH THE MANGOES IN TUB AND THEN CUTTING THEM WITH KNIFE AND GIVING THEM.


11. ON SUNDAY HIS WIFE TOLD THAT I HAVE GIVE SOME IMPORTANT PAPERS TO A CLIENT AND PLEASE COME TO OFFICE AND THE PAPERS WILL BE KEPT ON THE DESK ON REACHING OFFICE THEIR WERE NO PAPAERS THEREFORE I CALL HER AND SHE SAID THAT I HAVE SAID MY BROTHERS TO GIVE AND SO SIR IS ALSO ON THE WAY TO OFICE WHEN SIR REACH THER OFFICE YOU CAN GO ON REACHING SIR TOLD ME TO WAIT FOR ATLEAST HALF AN HOUR SINCE SOMEONE HAS TO COME CLIENTS CAME TO MEET HIM AND THEY WERE 5 IN NO.S AND MY CA TOLD ME ROOAFZA BANA KE DE DO SABKO.


12. ONE DAY MY FATHER WAS NOT WELL IN THE EVENING HE HAS ALREADY WOOMITING 15-20 TIMES SINCE EVENING TO MORNING AND THEREFORE MY FATHER CONDITION WAS NOT GOOD THEREFORE I DECIDED NOT TO GO OFFICE AS IT MIGHT THAT WE HAVE TO TAKE HIM TO HOSPITAL AND ON CALLING MAM IE SIR WIFE SHE TOLD ME KITNE BIMAR HAI, HOSPITAL KE BAAHIR CHOD KE YA PHIR ADMIT KARVA KE AAJANA .


13. ONE DAY HE TOLD AAJ KNIGHT LAGANI PADEGI BECAUSE OF WORK AND WORK I HAVE TO DO IS OFFICE KI DHOOL MITTI SAAF KARNA.


14. ACCORDING TO ME I HAVE WORKED MORE THAN 60 HRS EVERY WEEK.


15. EVERY DAY THEY SENT US FIELD JOBS IN DOING THEIR PERSONAL WORK AND THEN THEY SAY AB KNIGHT BHI LAGADO. AS IF I AM MACHINE.


16. MANY TIMES MY CA HAS TAKEN ME OUT WITH HIMSELF TO CARRY HIS BAG AS HE WANTS TO SHGOW SOMETHING TO THE CLIENT.


17. ACCORDING TO ME I LOST MY SELF RESPECT WHILE WORKING IN THAT FIRM.


BECAUSE OF ALL THESE REASONS I LEAVE THAT FIRM AND MY INTEREST IN CA FIELD WAS FINISHED.


WHEREEVER I GO TO CA FIRM FOR THE INTERVIEW THEY TOLD ME THAT WHATEVER WORK U HAVE DONE IS NOTHING MORE THAN BOOK KEEPING WORK AND FOR THEM IT IS NOTHING MORE THAN ZERO. BUT THIS IS THE HIGHEST LEVEL OF WORK THAT MY FIRM HAS AT PRESENT.


I WAS PAID A STIPEND OF 1500/- FROM THAT FIRM AND I HAVEN'T RECEIVED MY IMPREST EXPENSES AMOUNTING TO 2500/- HAS NOT BEEN PAID YET BUT THE ACTUAL IMPREST EXPENSES ARE EVEN MORE .


I HAVE LOST MY ONE YEAR ARTICLESHIP BECAUSE OF ALL THESE REASONS AND NOW I AM GETTING REGISTERED UNDER NEW EMPLOYER FOR THE BALANCE PERIOD.


I AM DOING CA JUST BECAUSE OF ONE REASON NOW IE I AM FINANCIALLY GOOD ENOUGH TO DO WHAT I WANT TO DO WITH MY CA AND IF HE IS READING THIS THIS ARTICLE HE WILL EASILY RECOGNISE ME WHO I AM AND I CAN PROMISE HIM WHEN I WANT HIM I WILL GET HIM AND THE WAY IN WHICH I WANT IT TO BE AND THAT IS A PROMISE.


Replies (23)

Can you please let me know the name of the firm. I am wih you. Reply soon.

Now, after reading your story i can say you were having some problems which can be easily tackled. You had following options;

(1) Filing a formal complaint with ICAI, Newdelhi stating that your serice is mis used by the employer/CA.

(2) If you are not satisfied with your employer, his way of working, you could have taken transfer.

(3) if you tell these story you u can not publish that "Great CA" name here.

Maan.... is all of that true??  Does this CA of yours know anything about  Professional Ethics ??  I am very happy for you that you got rid of the firm..but you should have done that a lot earlier i guess.... any ways what is gone is gone ...start afresh... ALL THE BEST !!!

Dont worry or lose your confidence study well and get good marks in CA final and become a good professional and you can complain to the ICAI regarding to claim the balance stipend if any as you know the ICAI rules are very strict regarding stipend payment ie the stipend should be deposited in bank account with account payee cheques only the ICAI will surely take action dont forget to give a feed back ok, all the best.

                                                                           yours faithfully

                                              shyam prasad.

One could only be a fool to do that. Sorry to use that word boss, but that's the way it is. Why do we all forget that we are associated with the best institution in India? So do it with pride. You could have taken the step much- much earlier. However, its never too late. Forget all those stuffs and make sure you don't become a victim to all of these anymore.

Wishing you all the very best for your future. 

u should have done something with Your CA otherwise he will continue to  slave other articles also.........

Something must be done. bcos this is not expected from a professional. this is pure professional ethics. 

tough times dont last; tough persons do.

u hav certainly proved to urslf that u r tough frm within. now use that toughness to be a better professional and then thr is ur entire left to get even with that sinister CA. and DO actually wht u said u will do. Get him someday!

Very Sad you had to face this hardship. You should have taken a transfer in the first month of your articleship only and not waited so long.

Anways all the best and hope you get a better CA this time.

 

Dear Mr Bajaj


Your Self respect is in your hand no one will come from outside to protect it.That was Just articleship and what will u do when the same will happen to u again in the job after Qualifying CA. I think its totally your mistake Dont let any one to dominate you.Even during my articleship my CA try to dominate me by throwing a file on me i responded by throwing the same file on him along with a warning that " Dont repeat such behaviour with me again". second month of my articleship.


Sorry for harsh words


Your friend


Rahul


 

THIS IS SHAMEFULL. My humble request would be that you inform this to Institute so that the person can not create problem with any one else.

SO PLEASE DO IT ASAP.

sorry yaar i regret for your sad experience

i think it is the time for u to forget the past and concentrate future aspects

remember one thing

FAILURES ARE THE STEPPING STONES TO SUCCESS

GOOD LUCK

ALL THE BEST

RAGHU

ETHICS ARE EXIST ONLY IN INSTITUTE STUDY MATERIAL THAN AMONG THE PRACTICE OF ITS MEMBERS.

FRIENDS , JUST COME OUT WITH YOUR INTOLERABLE PROBLEMS IN YOUR ARTICLESHIP.LET'S SHOW THE TRUE FACE OF CERTAIN MR.X AROUND THE COUNTRY. 


CCI Pro

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register