CA Student
891 Points
Joined August 2009
@ Praveen pandey
As per Book published for last attempt (i.e. nov 14), munish sir has made book his super revisible and deleted all case laws with hints ans which was there in earlier editions.
@ Tamanna
If u have time u shud read text book(comprehensive) for learning the concepts in detail and to know how to answer and what type of questions asked in previous attempts. also it covers many topics which is not covered in hand book (as per last edition). However what matters at last is that u shud know the all provisions of each section which frequently comes in exam. even u cover all ques given in text buk..u may forget with passage of time..what is more imp is to know all provision (possible with summary given in hand buk) during exam time rather than knowing and learning concepts in detail. I'm not disrespecting the concepts.. concepts do require for clear understanding and to enhance ur knowldge but as per law exam paper..they merely asks on conceptual basis...if u know the provision u can easily write ur answer.10% of the question alwys be tricky evn in all subjects but still i prefer to learn with conceptual understanding
For exam purpose..If u already decided to opt for munisg sir book, then best advise is to do handbook with practise manual. Cover PM with respective chap and i think thats enough.
Also u can do law from latest version of padhuka and then no need to do PM then as it covers evrything.
Crux: Answer to ur original ques: if want to use munish sir book: then Handbook plus PM of icai
if want to use paduka..then only paduka
Both book are great..u can choose anyone..
Best of luck..