Misprint in law paper ipcc may2014

IPCC 722 views 3 replies

IN PAPER NO. 02 i.e LAW IN IPCC EXAM MAY 2014 ONE QUESTION IS MISPRINTED. PAPER CODE “JCR” QUESTION NO. 1(b)

“Anson limited held equity shares in Booban limited. Lateron Anson limited became a subsidiary co. of Booban limited . Decide under the companies act 1956 whether it is necessary for Anson limited to surrender the equity shares of Booban limited ?”

 

In second line   “Lateron Anson limitedis wrongly printed.It should be written asLater on Anson limitedand due to this fault I answered question considering Lateron anson limited as company name & treated as different company from Anson limited according to companies act, 1956. & since both company is different so anson is not subsdiary of Booban limited so anson not need to surrender the equity shares. When I meet teacher & discuss answer he told me that this word is misprinted.

will i get any marks?  this qsn carry 5 marks.sad

 

 

Replies (3)
Element of common sense application was required at your end. It may not be a strong case to suggest there was gross error. Hence, the chances of your argument may not be visible to the examiner.

do you not think that i answered in common senseenlightened manner and why i cannot consider that lateron word as part of company name. it is clearly visible that taking lateron as part of name then also question is correct and in that sense applying common senseenlightened i answered correct...wink

I believe sonuji, jitni aap tension inn panch marks ki le rahe hain wo lene layak toh hai nahi!!!!! Why???

Bcs: firs,t common sense naam ki cheez chahiye hoti hai

Second, u are sitting in a CA exam

Third, U are attempting a CA exam and not that of an IAS kind of exam....


CCI Pro

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register