LIVE GST Certification Course by CA Arun Chhajer begins 27th April. Register Now!!

Lets move the High Court

ram rahim (Article Assistant) (188 Points)

28 May 2009

it seems that we have no resort left other than to move to Judicial Court to overturn the directions of ICAI in relation to transfer rules...

Therefore, I have decided to file writ in Mumbai or Delhi High Court in third week of June...

I request you all to pour in with your logical arguments to make our case stronger...I do not want sympathies, best wishes or similar stuff....all I want to good arguments...

Reply
Follow
Share

62 Replies

Rahim (Businessperson) (460 Points)
Replied 28 May 2009

Bonded Labour, Exploitation and above all no actuion against its Members by ICAI are the main reaons I am against these rules.

sam mugam (Chartered Management Accountant) (80 Points)
Replied 28 May 2009

I supports your move.

it's our fundamental right to change office to get better exposure.Unknowiling or because of lack of knowledge we may choose wrong office, where we can't get better exposure.If we don't change the office CA course may be curse for us. I also want to tell that most of the audit firm are doing outsourcing work rather than audit work and article student are implemented for that. Principle are getting data entry person in stipend rate. Is this good for student? If this decision is taken to stop the dummy article, then there are other strategies. This is the wrong move of institute. This decision will demoralise the student who wants to get better exposure. Because one office cannot give everything for student who is going to be CA tommorow. Most of the principle are using there low paid article assistant to pay the telephone bills , E.B. and wants to do there domestic work. What? Are we there servant? If we don't get a chance to transfer we should do that things for whole 3 and 1/2 years.is this good for student? I want logic behind the institute decision.

thanks friend, we are behind u and it's our fundamental right to change principle

1 Like

Subodh Niraula (PCC-Student Article Asistant) (187 Points)
Replied 28 May 2009

I FULLY SUPPORT UR MOVE...I FROM MY SIDE IS READY TO SUPPORT THIS CASE...I THINK THE FIRST MOVE SHOULD BE STARTED FROM DELHI ITSELF...WHY CANT WE ALL GATHER TOGETHER AT A DATE AND PUT PRESSURE TO ICAI..

WE ALL NEED TO DO SOMETHING TO UPRAISE OURSELF.

Karthik (C A Student) (219 Points)
Replied 28 May 2009

are you filing a case or a petition Ram ?

CA Amit Pandya (CA, M.com) (419 Points)
Replied 28 May 2009

Originally posted by :Karthik
"	are you filing a case or a petition Ram ?	"

It's against human rights.

so you can file petition also.

ram rahim (Article Assistant) (188 Points)
Replied 28 May 2009

whether it would be form of petition or writ would depend on the extent of research we all can pull in...in case we file a writ, we would require to court judicial pronouncements...rules at similarly placed organizations, etc...in petition we need only to plead injustice...so it depends how things pan out in next few days...however, I am in favor of one solid writ backed by several individuals petitions filed by article assistants

1 Like

Karthik (C A Student) (219 Points)
Replied 28 May 2009

ok Amit,

You have all our support Ram, just let us know what we can do !!

CA Amit Pandya (CA, M.com) (419 Points)
Replied 28 May 2009

you r correct man

kirthi (student) (88 Points)
Replied 28 May 2009

I Truly Appreciate Your Cause and Pledge my support through this forum.

HALLA BOL AGAINST ALL THOSE WHO EXPLOIT & PLAY WITH OUR FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT OF CHOICE.

IF INSTITUTE THINKS IT IS BENEFICIAL FOR US.

THEN THEY SHOULD CONSIDER VOTING AMONG ALL THE PRESENT CA STUDENTS.

AND IF VOTE CAST VOTES AGAINST ARE MORE THAN THE IN FAVOUR THEN INSTITUTE SHOULD NEW RULES OF TRANSFER

ISIKO TOH DEMOCRACY KEHTE HAI SIRJEE!!! WHAT AN IDEA SIRJEE!!!

Sumit Jain (CA) (4760 Points)
Replied 28 May 2009

very good step ahead

these notification just binding the students

and giving the powers to CA to use their articles

which is injustice

RAMANJU (here to updating the knowledge) (485 Points)
Replied 28 May 2009

The Institute decision gives the principle members to make use of articles left and right in whatsoever manner they desire. They should also be put in a position of undoing. Is'nt it?

Sourabh Sharma (CS CA (Final) M.com NCFM Derivative Capital Market Mutual Funds) (771 Points)
Replied 28 May 2009

Yes i support you too. Here is something to make the mood lighter.............

There is a Banner posted on th icai building

" DRIVE SLOWLY........................ DON'T KILL OUR STUDENTS...............................LEAVE THEM TO US..................."

Rishabh Mishra (C.A Final) (144 Points)
Replied 28 May 2009

HIIII RAM,....... A VERY GOOD STEP INDEED....I FULLY SUPPORT UR MOVE AND JUST DONT THINK THAT U ARE ALONE....WE...ALL CA STUDENTS OF ARE WITH U....AND U CAN CONTACT ANYONE OF US ANYTIME FOR HELP IF REQUIRED.....AND REGARDING LOGICAL ARGUMENTS FOR UR CASE :

1. BAN ON TRANSFER LIMITS SCOPE OF LEARNING FOR STUDENTS

2. OUR OVERALL CAREER AT THE MERCY OF OUR CAs

3. INHUMAN BEHAVIOUR AT SOME OFFICES WITH ARTICLES.

4. UNNECESSARY POWERS GIVEN TO MEMBERS OF THE INSTITUTE

5. NO REGULATION BY THE INSTITUTE FOR MEMBERS GIVING DUMMY ARTICLES.