Ad-Free CAclubindia and daily updates on your mobile. Subscribe Now!

IS PRIME ACADEMY BEST??

CA Raviteja (Risk Management) (585 Points)

05 October 2010

Friends, my Final attempt is due in NOV - 11. I wish to take coaching in early next year at chennai.... Im planning to take all subjects at PRIME.... i know it is gud for 1st grp and Gurukripa for 2nd grp.... but i feel it diff to adjust timings between the two institutes. i also hav limited leave for coaching...... IS IT FINE IF I TAKE ALL SUBS AT PRIME???? PLS GUIDE ME......

Reply
Follow
Share

18 Replies

ReevCA (Absolute Carnage ) (145 Points)
Replied 05 October 2010

As per my experience Prime's Best coaching subject is Financial Reporting By Mr. MPV... I Don't know other subjects..

1 Like

CA.G.Muguntha Narayanan (Internal Auditor at TVS Motors) (2195 Points)
Replied 05 October 2010

Dear Ravi,

My suggestion wud be,

D.T.-Mr.Manoharan,

IDT-Mr.Vaiteeshwaran (He took classes in Sankara)

Law - Mr.Jayaraman,

I m not sure about the other subjects. Prime s gud for the subjects taken by Mr.M.P.Vijayakumar. But i have not attended any of his classes. So i hav no right to give any suggesstions. But for the aboved said subjects, the above said professors are the best

1 Like

CA Aravind (CA) (255 Points)
Replied 05 October 2010

I would suggest u not take coaching for all the subjects.However i have attended the following coaching in chennai and found to be useful

Accounts-MPV(prime academy)

SFM-Pattabhi(Prime academy)

Law and audit-it is better to do self study

If u want to take coachin then wait for L.jayaraman to start his classes in chennai

There is another option.Mr B.Ravi of srisabkara coaching is too good for law.I have attended his classes for PCC .He is a regular visiting faculty of ICAI.

Audit -If u want to attend classes,then there are 3 options

1st preffered choice would be S.Ganapthy(he conducts classes independently)

or u can opt for R.Murali or saraswathi murali

Costing-S.S.Rajamouli(MT Educare)

Isca-Do self study or attend R.Chandrasekhar of prime academy

Direct tax-1St choice is T.G.Suresh(maruthi coaching) or i heard that mr T.N.manoharan has started taking classes from may 10.Even this could be a better option

IDT-Join NS Govindan(Maruthi coaching) or Vaitheswaran(Sankara coaching).Both are good

My sincere advise is not to join gurukripa for any of the subjects as they are too fast .they complete the subject in 2 months and u cant understand anything bcoz of the pace at which they teach.Probably one can join saravan prasad for costing and not for any other subjects

2 Like

NIVED C P (ca final student) (320 Points)
Replied 05 October 2010

hey the best option

a/cs-mpv(prime academy)

law-jayaraman sir

audit-vikas oswal(mt educare) or ganapathi sir

mafa-mt educare or pattabhi(prime)

costing-mt educare or saravana prasath(gurukripa)

idt-vaideeshwaran(sankara)

dt-mt educare

mics-rajeshwar (sankara)

DONT DO ALL @ PRIME............ @ GURUKRIPA COSTING IS GRT.BT OTHERS R NOT SO GOOD....

2 Like

CA Abdul Haseeb (Employed) (147 Points)
Replied 06 October 2010

my humble suggestion .. join anywhere for anything but for Gods sake dont join G sekars classs. its waste of money, time and moreover its a mental harassment...

anyways jokes apart..

u need not join all the 8 subjects .. certain subjects should be done at own for a person who has passed PCC... like auditing, Info tech, and to some extent law.. for other subjects...

acc- there 's no other choice other than MPV .. u cant find a person who keeps every student on their heels while doing a problem .. the way he takes u through a problem is really really great... and certain things which are difficult to understand, he makes it really easy.. i can write a lot more of praise but this is fair enough....

SFM- pattabhi//// he is good ... but not as awesome as MPV...

law- if needed jayaraman (i haven attended , but all say he is the best) he will have 1 month classes - 4hrs a day... somewhere in jan... timings wont clash with other classes..

audit - not needed at all..

ad. mgmt - dont attend primes sivakumar.. his level is beyond CA... oly people of very very high IQ can catch hold of his toe(this is personal experience , as i ve attended his class for some days)... i have got positive opinion abt MT educare .. u cant join saravana prasath class coz.... if u join his class then u shld also sacrifice ur mental peace by joining G sekars class... don ever make this blunder...

DT- TG suresh is good but as TN manoharan , the experts expert is into the teaching field .. he is the no.1 choice..

IDT - vaitheeswaran rules this... but the timings will clash with someother class surely... Mohd rafi of prime is a good option.. people say he is good..

Info tech..... NO IDEA so no opinion...

such a long reply .. hope u r not bored..

1 Like

CA Raviteja (Risk Management) (585 Points)
Replied 06 October 2010

Thank u one n all.... i wud surely consider all ur suggestions be4 takin my coaching..... :) Can anyone tell me when r Mteducare next batch classes for Final gonna start?? their website doesnt provide complete details.......

Teja sree Palem (student) (78 Points)
Replied 06 October 2010

Hie..Ravi teja....I took my Final coaching at chennai....

ACCOUNTS-MPV sir is hte best... @ Prime

MAFA-PAttabhi sir @ Prime...

LAW-Jayraman sir...

Auditing-u can do it on ur own...

COSTING-please donot join gurukripa......even though costing is good u r forced to take DT

along with costing its waste of time and money....Sekhar he wont take class except publicity abt his institute....

IDT-VAitheeswaran at Sankara......

MICS also @ sankara.........

u need nt worry about timings u can manage them very well.........

1 Like

Radhika (CA Final) (194 Points)
Replied 06 October 2010

that was awesome abdul. nice RD and analysis

Bharath (C.A,C.S) (3983 Points)
Replied 06 October 2010

Hey frnd,..i too have been a student of prime and i found it useful only for accounts and mafa...try to go for gurukripa for costing and dt,..

instead of chennai PUNE is a nice option,...AS foundation academy is good,..

so make a move there too,...

ALL THE BEST

1 Like

CA Raviteja (Risk Management) (585 Points)
Replied 07 October 2010

Bharath, i too heard about AS foundation (Pune). Is it gud for all subs???

Bharath (C.A,C.S) (3983 Points)
Replied 07 October 2010

ya ravi,..my frnds have been there recently for all subjects,....they say its good,...the standard is nice,..

accounts mafa and auditing vinod kumar agarwal sir,....his teaching is nice,..u l surely get benefitted,..

i l get u back with further details after enquring with my frnds,..ok,..

but dnt adopt prime for all subjects,.

INSTEAD OF THAT IF U INVEST THE MONEY IN FIXED DEPOSITS U L GET A NICE RETURN,..HE HE

CA Raviteja (Risk Management) (585 Points)
Replied 07 October 2010

Haha.... u were applying Capital budgeting analysis here also.......

CA Raviteja (Risk Management) (585 Points)
Replied 07 October 2010

hie tejasree..... ur saying v can manage time.... but how?? srisankara's classes clash with MPV's sirs classes..... so how come have u managed??? did u take coaching twice???????