Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Icwai exam query

Azim Khan ACA,CS,CMA*,LLB* (Proprietor) (1312 Points)

08 March 2013  

Inter Result For December 2012 Term


Name of Student :

Urusha A Khan

Roll No :


Registration No:


Syllabus :



Paper 5

Paper 6

Paper 7


Group I







Paper 8

Paper 9

Paper 10


Group II





The captioned student got exmeption in the Paper 5 & 7 based on the ICSI qualification.
It is known that the exmeption obtained in the paper 8 can not be carried forward because as per ICWAI rules, one should secure minimum 40 marks in other papers in order to carry forward the exemption. So, he need to give the all papers of Group-II.
My query is that Is the person cleared the Group-I though he secured 52 marks in Paper 6 and should fill up the exam form for the Group-II only? i am asking this because it is mentioned A instead of E in the papers in which exmeption is alloted..
Please reply at your earliest convenience.


 12 Replies

Ankit Gupta (Learner) (1552 Points)
Replied 08 March 2013


  • In marks 'A' means - Absent
  • 'D' means - Not Applied
  • 'E'/'F' means - Exempted. 

Kindly please inquire with the People concerned from Institute itself that why is it mentioned 'A' instead of E/F. (as the case maybe). 

And secondly why i am not able to view the result of this registration number of Intermediate which you have provided above ? 

Thirdly, If your above result says you have completed gropu I then, Apply only for group II, ?And the exemption scored will be carried forward to the next attempt. 

And securing minimum 40 to claim exemption in an attempt is the rule of ICWAI? 
Please kindly tell me the source.

Azim Khan ACA,CS,CMA*,LLB* (Proprietor) (1312 Points)
Replied 08 March 2013

Ankit, instead of giving suggestions u started asking me the questions......

Source is the prospectus of ICWAI, now dont tell to provide u the link...............

Ankit Gupta (Learner) (1552 Points)
Replied 08 March 2013

Sir,I apolozise. I just now saw the exemption rule in the prospectus.


On the basis of examination :
 If a candidate is unsucessful in passing a group but secures 60% on more 
in any paper & minimum 40% marks in each of the remaining papers of 
the group, he shall be exempted in that paper(s) from appearing in the 
immediately successive three terms of examination.
On the basis of qualification :
 Students desirous to seek the exemptions shall apply in the 
prescribed format to the Director of Studies at least 60 days prior to the 
start of the ICAI examination in which he/she wishes to appear, alongwith 
copies of testimonials in support of the claim and the exemption fees of ` 
200/- per paper by way of Demand Draft favouring “The Institute of Cost 
Accountants of India” payable at Kolkata.


@ Azim Sir, agreed with Ankit, the said student need to clarify it with institue officials, as why its showing A instead of E.., as one need to show exempted subjects in respective column in exam forms.. or it may be an error from institute side...

As per prospectus, For Exemption: if one gets 60% or more in any paper/or papers and is unsuccessful in passing a grp, he will get exemption in that paper in subsequent examination, but marks will be reckoned as 50

For Carry forward of marks: 60% or more in any paper, and min 40% of marks in all subjects, but unsuccessful in passing a grp, then he will get exemption AND he will get benefit of carry forward of actual marks of that paper in subsequent exam..

As per my belief, in your case, the student will get exemption in paper 8, but his marks will be taken as 50 in calculating aggregate in the next exam...

 but suggest you to confirm it with officials, or call 18003450092...


@ Ankit, you can see the details regd exemption on pge 23 of the ICAI (Cost) prospectus.., or check the link here...



1 Like

Azim Khan ACA,CS,CMA*,LLB* (Proprietor) (1312 Points)
Replied 08 March 2013

Thanks Ankit and Harini....


As per the link provided by Harini, it is understood that in the given case, the person is required to be appeared in Operation Mgt & in Indirect taxes and no need to be appeared in Costing as secured 63 Marks...

Thanks a lot.....

And as far as A or F is concerned, the mistake is made by the students in evey case who got exemption based on CS qualification.... I will nevertheless advise to visit the regional chapter for this query.....



vidhi (CMA) (21 Points)
Replied 02 April 2014

in how many item icwai final exemption will be carry forwad

Jagadeesh (Student CA Final ) (8 Points)
Replied 16 June 2017

Sir I get one exemption in CMA final, when I apply for exam through online there is no details about in exam application form, then how can I get exemption? Whether i should attend the exam or not?

aravind (Business) (131 Points)
Replied 24 September 2017

Dear Jagadeesh

i also got 60 % in one paper 

what you hav edone to get that exemption

CA Rashmi Gandhi (Chartered Accountant) (59008 Points)
Replied 01 October 2017

I thought today you are posting this for advwrtisment only.

As earlier Anushka Sen posted on all post & now you are doing same..

I think its a fake publicity.....

Ashiwini Ballodia (Founder of TAXounting - Tax & Accounting Consultant)   (8705 Points)
Replied 19 October 2017

Sorry to say that Aaditya Sir may be good for Delhi. But in Kolkata he is cheating the students.
At the time of admission the staff are saying live class but afterwards all recorded classes has been provided that to video are 2 to 3 years old.
Aaditya Jain has cheated me and my entire batch.
I am happy to say that because of me atleast 50 students has not taken coaching from Aaditya Jain Sir and gone to Sanjay Saraf Sir.
Only money minded people, no professionalism at all.

CA Rashmi Gandhi (Chartered Accountant) (59008 Points)
Replied 23 October 2017

Stop chetaing student & commenting using fake ids.......

I noticed your activites on CCI.....

Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register  

Related Threads


Subscribe to the latest topics :
Search Forum:

Trending Tags