ICAI shud take step against PWC. Black day for CA's

Stat Audit 1094 views 2 replies

The Satyam fraud is not the sole brush with infamy for Pricewaterhouse, one of the world's top auditing firms. Pricewaterhouse is already in deep trouble in relation to its suspect auditing of the collapsed Global Trust Bank, for which it is being probed by the disciplinary committee of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI).
In the GTB case, Pricewaterhouse was hauled up for alleged negligence in auditing of books of the bank and failing to detect huge levels of NPAs. The NPAs had accumulated due to massive exposure made by the erstwhile bank into the stock market, which Pricewaterhouse is alleged to have overlooked.

In another instance, Lovelock & Lewes — another auditing entity of PricewaterhouseCoopers (PwC) — was the auditor of DSQ Software, which was found guilty of manipulating share prices and falsification of accounts by Serious Fraud Investigation Office (SFIO) of the ministry of corporate affairs.

Now again PWC is the statutory auditor of Satyam Computers who has done a biggest ever financial scam in India. So now we need to re-understand the role of auditor and the meaning of corporate governance. We all are expecting a strong step against PWC now because if we can't rely upon the audit like PWC then how we can rely on other auditors.

As a chartered accountant I personally fill it is a black day for CA's. As a Chartered accountant I never accept this situation. Mr Ved Jain, the president of ICAI has told to PTI - " ICAI will write a letter to PwC on 8 January and will seek an immediate reply on the issue and inform them about the process of investigation, which is on. We will ensure that to any person who has not worked according to our standards and our expectations, severe punishment be given. ”  I am expecting that ICAI will take a very strong decision because I proud to be a Chartered Accountant and I proud for ICAI. ICAI need to take appropriate action against PWC to give a proper massage to every CA that ICAI will not allow any CA not having professional ethics.

 

Replies (2)

Strictest posssible penalisation should be carried out for PwC. It should be exemplary in a way that in future no firm ever even thinks in dreams to subvert audit. Among all other things how could they ever certify wrong cash position? They are the biggest culprits. In fact even bigger than the Raju family and Directors. Atleast to start with ICAI should debar the PWC team personnel till the enquiries are over, and make the public announcement to this effect - to preempt any coverup.The independent directors, internal auditors, Senior Finance personnel of Satyam & associated comapnies and accountants (PwC) should have their passports revoked to prevent them from running away, better still would be take them under preventive police custody as this was a clear case of dereliction of their fiduciary duties. Also crippling fines should be levied on PwC so that they have no option but to liquidate themselves - this shall send a strong message down the spine of these white-collared crooks.

I agree with you sir. But we should first deeply think about the reasons that caused such a thing so its not repeated again


CCI Pro

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register