In my opinion the answer to above mentioned is wrong. Can you confirm?
Also confirm if proviso to sec 167(1)(a) amended by cos amendment act 2017 is applicable for May 2018 exam.
Menu
Final-LAW- N17- Q1(a) (iii)
Replies (22)
Can you please provide the link or paste the answer which you're referring
Check out
Paper - 4 : Corporate and Allied Laws : Suggested Answer November 2017 https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.interactivemedia.students&referrer=utm_source%3Dshare%26utm_campaign%3Dvia_app
Paper - 4 : Corporate and Allied Laws : Suggested Answer November 2017 https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.interactivemedia.students&referrer=utm_source%3Dshare%26utm_campaign%3Dvia_app
This link takes to Google play store
I know. but I'm not able to post picture
here is the link
https://resource.cdn.icai.org/48237bos32270p4.pdf
here is the link
https://resource.cdn.icai.org/48237bos32270p4.pdf
As per my opinion the answer is correct, Mr Vikram would he have to vacate his office even if the defaulting company is a private company
in ans (i) vikram has to vacate his office in tubelight ltd but not greenligjt ltd, which is correct answer. in (iii) the say the and is same as above but further say that je will have to vacate office in BOTH companies, which is wrong in my opinion.
I agree with you, he should not have to vacate his office in green light limited, but private companies can provide additional grounds of disqualification under it's article. May be assumption le kr green Ltd se vacate kiya ho but hona nahi chahiye get green Ltd.
assumption toh ICAI na nahi likha hao. Thanks :)
I know but as per the provisions of law answer isn't correct. Ya Toh question should have mentioned more details about company's articles
exactly. An suggested and hi wrong ho toh imagine kitne Sahi log fail hue havi aur kitne halat log pass hue hai.
Ni aisa ni h. Even institute disclaimer deta h about suggested answers. Checking process Bhot refine rehti h. Kafi bar pm k answers bhi galat rehte h. Suggested k bhi galat hotey h. It's alright.
C'mon yar that disclaimer is given by every educational institute and every author and every publisher about not being responsible regarding mistakes in the contents of the material. That is to save themselves in legal disputes. SM PM RTP Suggested Answer sab me galtiyaan hai. But specifically regarding Suggested answer, it proves that checking me bhi mistakes hue hai. Why will they issue wrong answer if they have correct answer with them used in checking. The reason is that they don't.
New course ka material Dekha h Kitna improvement hua h?
Are you under new course? No mane nahi dekha. But already found one mistake in rtp regarding IBC 2016 question. So I know for sure new syllabus me wo mistake hogi.
Recent Threads
- Où décidez-vous le rythme du jeu?
- Gst in Turnover
- GST Tax invoice Govt.agency
- CAN ICAI EXAMINER'S REMUNERATION BE TAXED U/S 44AD
- Applicability of IGST or CGST/SGST
- Form 26AS Glitch
- Credit counseling services
- Solve questions
- Tax clarification on rental income
- Long term capital loss on Indexation on sale of Re
Related Threads
CAclubindia
