CCI Online Learning
What do you want to learn today?
     
CIBIL

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Eform chg-1 vs e-form chg-9 (difference in charge and charge for debenture?)


Abhay (Others)     30 July 2019

Abhay
Others 
 37 points

| My Other Post

I understand that Form CHG-1 is for creation or modification of a charge whereas EForm CHG-9 is for creation or modification of charge for debenture. I am unable to understand the difference between a charge and charge for debenture. Can members please clarify the difference between the two here and also in what circumstances which form is used.

Thanking you in anticipation. 

avater

Livetolearn1255 (Article Assisstant)     30 July 2019

Livetolearn1255
Article Assisstant 
 7 likes  192 points

View Profile | My Other Post

May be CHG-1 is used when company takes loan from Banks/FI and charge is created over its assets and CHG-9 is filed only in case of debentures.

 

Abhay (Others)     31 July 2019

Abhay
Others 
 37 points

View Profile | My Other Post

But what is the difference then as even in Form CHG-9 loan is secured through assets of the company.

Chirag (Professional)     23 August 2019

Chirag
Professional 
 64 likes  749 points

View Profile | My Other Post

Charge is a lien /mortgage created on the assets of the company, Or purchase of any property subject to charge, Now,Company Can create charge(security ),Not only when it took loan from Banks and Financial Institution,While also on pledge /Hypothecation and on book debts(Floating Charge), To differentiate that such charge (security) is being created for such purpose or only for securing debenture, Separate forms are required to be filled,and banks/fi don't allow pari passu charge on Debentures on same security (assets of company)

Abhay (Others)     23 August 2019

Abhay
Others 
 37 points

View Profile | My Other Post

Thank you, Chirag for the explanation. So in case the company takes secyred loan from bank on certain assets, will there be a separate Form CHG-1 and Form CHG-9 filed or only Form CHG-9 will be filed

Chirag (Professional)     23 August 2019

Chirag
Professional 
 64 likes  749 points

View Profile | My Other Post

CHG -9 shall be filed only in case, When company Is creating charge for securing the debentures, In favour of Debenture Trustee, For bank loan (Which is secured) then will file CHG-1....and with Effect from 2.11.18 ( CHG-1/CHG-9 to be filed within 30 days), If delay happens then in next 60 days, if again delay happens In next days 60 days ..Previously it was 300days

Hope it clears to you..
CS CHIRAG

Abhay (Others)     24 August 2019

Abhay
Others 
 37 points

View Profile | My Other Post

Thanks a lot, Chirag.

 

mihir.b.joshi (student)     05 March 2020

mihir.b.joshi
student 
 22 points

View Profile | My Other Post

if suppose A Pvt Ltd issued Debentures and B Pvt Ltd given its land as a security to secure the Debentures issued by the A Pvt Ltd to debenture holder so here which form B Pvt Ltd will file whether CHG-1 or CHG-9?


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register  



Related Threads


Loading

Popular Discussion


view more »



Trending Tags
cbdt
aatmanirbhar bharat
audit
law
dgft
itc
Union Budget
gst portal
companies act 2013
gst return
sebi
llp
taxpayers
exams
VAT
shares stock
gstr 9
coronavirus
csr
tcs
icsi
traces
Excise
icai
gst
epfo