Download today's costing paper before 5 pm

Page no : 2

Megha Maheshwari (WORKING- JOB) (68 Points)
Replied 11 November 2011

"Is 3(b) sums on transfer pricing WRONG???

Its says that B is used as an Input IN A, and then they are asking to find the TP for A to B.....i m confused

yes.. it is a ques from transfer pricing.. What shud div. A charge from B.. Answer is to be based on A's point of view. that is d reason 'transeferring Division A to B' is written there.. I guess..

Mayank Saraogi (Learner) (170 Points)
Replied 11 November 2011

Originally posted by : Megha
	"Is 3(b) sums on transfer pricing WRONG??? Its says that B is used as an Input IN A, and then they are asking to find the TP for A to B.....i m confused yes.. it is a ques from transfer pricing.. What shud div. A charge from B.. Answer is to be based on A's point of view. that is d reason 'transeferring Division A to B' is written there.. I guess..

nice interpretation...but i think u r contradicting the 3rd line i.e. TP to be adapted by trnsferring div A to div B

Megha Maheshwari (WORKING- JOB) (68 Points)
Replied 11 November 2011

Originally posted by : Mayank Saraogi
	Originally posted by : Megha "Is 3(b) sums on transfer pricing WRONG??? Its says that B is used as an Input IN A, and then they are asking to find the TP for A to B.....i m confused yes.. it is a ques from transfer pricing.. What shud div. A charge from B.. Answer is to be based on A's point of view. that is d reason 'transeferring Division A to B' is written there.. I guess.. nice interpretation...but i think u r contradicting the 3rd line i.e. TP to be adapted by trnsferring div A to div B

Hey.. em not contradicting.. the language itself is confusing.. nywayz.. it waz just a guess.. i was confused.. so i didn't attemppt it.. :)

Mayank Saraogi (Learner) (170 Points)
Replied 11 November 2011

@ megha anyways thnx..that was a quite a help

Sasidhar Aruljothi (C.A FINAL) (187 Points)
Replied 11 November 2011

paper was lengthy........but questions were all direct....no twistings....was not very tough kavya..........

Jigar (Student) (661 Points)
Replied 11 November 2011

I found it ok

person with good conceptual backgrnd can easily solve it

nd for marks v all know how ICAI awrds it so no comments

CA Parth Jain (CA) (185 Points)
Replied 11 November 2011

Anuj ji whn u will giv ur ca final exm on tht day i'll upload costing paper at 1 pm.so tht paper will get cancel.ok?man i know many of ansrs bt i didn't write coz i know i can't clear d whole grp so i thought atleast i can help CCI members to give fast service.thts nly reason i left my class rum witout thinking tht wht rest students will comment on me..

CA Parth Jain (CA) (185 Points)
Replied 11 November 2011

Sneha m not against 2 write both grps..i was preparing 4 costing n coz of death of my close frnd i repeat 1st grp only n left 2nd grp der.m always wit both grp studies.u should also go 4 both d grp.

CA Parth Jain (CA) (185 Points)
Replied 11 November 2011

Ankur ji it's not pink colour....coz of sun light effect it's luk like pink...Camera quality was 25 Mp (Sony Handicam,i tried my bst 2 giv best quality)sorry i don't hv scaner at home.......nxt tym i will try to snap in dark...if u want more proper copy like Original thn nxt tym plz don't try b4 5 pm...my service is only 4 those who want paper b4 5 pm..let's enjoy othrs who want it by 3.30 pm

Ankur (CA Final Student) (999 Points)
Replied 11 November 2011

Originally posted by : Parth
	Ankur ji it's not pink colour....coz of sun light effect it's luk like pink...Camera quality was 25 Mp (Sony Handicam,i tried my bst 2 giv best quality)sorry i don't hv scaner at home.......nxt tym i will try to snap in dark...if u want more proper copy like Original thn nxt tym plz don't try b4 5 pm...my service is only 4 those who want paper b4 5 pm..let's enjoy othrs who want it by 3.30 pm

no........no...........it was not for you.........another member had posted the paper with pink watermark......urs was good...

CA Anuj (Chartered Accountant) (230 Points)
Replied 12 November 2011

Originally posted by : Parth
	Anuj ji whn u will giv ur ca final exm on tht day i'll upload costing paper at 1 pm.so tht paper will get cancel.ok?man i know many of ansrs bt i didn't write coz i know i can't clear d whole grp so i thought atleast i can help CCI members to give fast service.thts nly reason i left my class rum witout thinking tht wht rest students will comment on me..

It was a joke not meant to offend anyone.

Jayant (CA, CS Final) (171 Points)
Replied 12 November 2011

Originally posted by : MIRAJ M MEHTA
	hey thanks for ur fast service............................

Jayant (CA, CS Final) (171 Points)
Replied 12 November 2011

Originally posted by : MIRAJ M MEHTA
	hey thanks for ur fast service............................

CA Parth Jain (CA) (185 Points)
Replied 12 November 2011

Anuj ji u will not understand d feeling of those students who prepared d exm well n after writing it thy come to know tht paper is cancel coz paper out ho gaya......it's happen wit me whn i was in CPT...u remember aug 2007 attemp ? 2 tymes i wrote exm....1st on 5th aug thn again on 26th aug it was vry panic for me thts y m telling u tht don't expect paper b4 distribution in d class.