Live Course on Drafting of Appeal and Reply of Penalty Notice by CA Sachin Sinha. Register Now!!

Does the Govt hear our voices!!

CA Nikita (Chartered Accountant) (4158 Points)

18 February 2008

Hi Friends,

In the democratic system of govt.. when we make our govt, sudn't we get an opportunity to have a more authorative say in the budget..

i welcome ur views...

Reply
Follow
Share

18 Replies

CA. Amit Daga (Finance Controller CA. CS. CFA. CIFRS. M.COM. ) (9017 Points)
Replied 18 February 2008

Hi Nikita, I am agreed with you but practically its next to impossible.Indias current population is more than 110 crores and you know capabe person who can give logical reason behind budget is less than 1 lacs ...if they will go acc to you than govt have to do survey and in survey everybody have a right to speak and right to vote ..so that result will not be correct.Therefore i think they cant do.. and for your information i let you know that budget is not only prepared by finance minster lots of deserving people are assoicated with him in the making of budget..and dont mind even i think me and you (who have a good understanding) dont have any right to make any kind of question on there intigrety,we can give our opinion,but we cant raise a question mark? ...thisis my view...i dont know abt others Thanks & Regards Amit Daga

CA. Dashrath Maheshwari (TaXpert) (15090 Points)
Replied 18 February 2008

dagaji, aap barabar bole riya ho, aa chiz to vastav main sambhav koni. panh govt. ne koi dujo tariko nikalno chaize. aaj kaal to takniky kitti bawaal machhay ri hai. eeko faydo liyo jaa sake hai. media aur aapni CaClubIndia jedi websitaan ro bhi faydo leno chaize... Nikitaji ri baat bhi thik heej hai, kayan bhi sarkar ne aapa ri baat sunani chaize... khas kar banya pdhya loga ri...

CA. Amit Daga (Finance Controller CA. CS. CFA. CIFRS. M.COM. ) (9017 Points)
Replied 18 February 2008

maheshwarije peheli bat toh marwari mai jawab sunkar kafi chokho lagayego...nahi toh agar thori bat per gaur kiyo jaye toh sirf ek tariko hai... govt ne sari renound institues aur authority(like c.a,c.s,c.w.a,iims etc) su opinion leleno chahiye..aur aye university ne aapri website mai ek pvt forum bana leno chahiye jime sirf ya toh member aur be student jo certain level per hai i.e final mai.. aur bohri opinion leni chahiye aur fir inst ne ek commitee banani chahiye aur ba commitee ne sare comments ne evaluate karno chahiye aur apro opinion wapas su publish karna chahiye aur wapas su members aur student re feedback leno chahiye aur bine fir su evaluatie kareke finance minster ne bhej deni chahiye... mahre ishab su sirf ohi ek tariko hai thone kuch lage toh kahoo..

CA. Amit Daga (Finance Controller CA. CS. CFA. CIFRS. M.COM. ) (9017 Points)
Replied 18 February 2008

aur ek bat aapo banya agar phada likhiya be na hotoh rupeeya paise mai vidwan ne bhi fail kardoo..aur galti su aaptoh phada likhiya banya hoo hahahhahahahahaha

CA. Dashrath Maheshwari (TaXpert) (15090 Points)
Replied 18 February 2008

gani chhokhi baat

CA. Amit Daga (Finance Controller CA. CS. CFA. CIFRS. M.COM. ) (9017 Points)
Replied 18 February 2008

hahahahhahah

SUSHAMA (TAX CONSULTANT) (162 Points)
Replied 19 February 2008

I do fall in with what Mr.Amit Daga's opinion to Nikita

CA Nikita (Chartered Accountant) (4158 Points)
Replied 19 February 2008

Hi, I made that statement keeping in mind the technology upgrading that is happenin in gthe country... ITdept and mostly all govt dept's r now beomin net savvy that sud help us to put our points fwd... wat do u say???

CA. Amit Daga (Finance Controller CA. CS. CFA. CIFRS. M.COM. ) (9017 Points)
Replied 19 February 2008

Thank you suushma, hey Nikita,Think Practically and tell me how they can do.. you know in my lost job, from my manager i was learn just one thing that when ever you say this is a problem,than you have to come with a solution..Otherwise you have no right to say that this is a Problem. Hope you got my Point.Tell me your view how it will be possible?

Amit Khandelia (Analyst) (125 Points)
Replied 19 February 2008

I feel there is a point in what Nikita is saying...Common man should have a say in what is presented to them in budget..Right now, it is only the ruling party which dictates the budget and when it is election time, you expect the fin min to give all kind of sops but it is the other way round in first or second year of budget when he squeezes money out of the system... Whatever, Nikita has said has got some substance but at the same time difficukt to implement..But if ROC can be made electronic, whats the big deal in getting common man heard through electronic means and let their demands take shape in the budget... Where there is a will, there is a way...

CA. Amit Daga (Finance Controller CA. CS. CFA. CIFRS. M.COM. ) (9017 Points)
Replied 21 February 2008

Amit just read my first message and say me howz is it possible yar..india mai 110 crore rahte hai ..aur knowledgable less than 1 lacs and u know i am sure yar jitne opinion aayege usmai se 10 times jyada fake bakwas aur bina sir paw ke honge and you cant help it

CA. Dashrath Maheshwari (TaXpert) (15090 Points)
Replied 21 February 2008

Daga bhai ji , Aap Sahi keh rahe ho, Kehna aasaan hain, Maan lo agar esha hota aur un sab suggestions ka compilation ka kaam Nikita ji ko Diya jaata to....

CA Nikita (Chartered Accountant) (4158 Points)
Replied 21 February 2008

Hi, Well lemme tell u all one thing.. In this system none works alone... There's a team which handles the whole process of compilation... as it works even for C & AG...(the team for C&AG compiles the whole accounts of the country) so do u still feel that compiling intellectual people's suggestions will be that difficult... See for anything to start.. we need to climb one ladder and then the process leads to the ultimate goal... I feel this can be achieved...