Page no : 4

CA Karan Joshi (ACA) (149 Points)
Replied 11 November 2011

hello frnz..

hw was costing for all of u ???

mine was good.

did any one found any mistake in question no. 1 (i) and question 3 (b) ???

Vidit Seth (Practicing CA) (76 Points)
Replied 11 November 2011

was a avg paper for me...not so good as last 3 but better than accounts...which ques r u talking abt

CA Goush Abdulla (Chartered Accountant) (81 Points)
Replied 11 November 2011

today's paper was quite tuff ! ICAI ne sab ki band baja di.

ritesh (CA) (106 Points)
Replied 11 November 2011

 Originally posted by : karan joshi hello frnz.. hw was costing for all of u ???   mine was good.   did any one found any mistake in question no. 1 (i) and question 3 (b) ???

which part are u refering towards??

CA Karan Joshi (ACA) (149 Points)
Replied 11 November 2011

hello frnz..

hw was costing for all of u ???

mine was good.

did any one found any mistake in question no. 1 (i) and question 3 (b) ???

ritesh (CA) (106 Points)
Replied 11 November 2011

hi karan... can u specify exactly what is that u find wrong in those questions..?

CA Karan Joshi (ACA) (149 Points)
Replied 11 November 2011

m talking abt ques 1 (i)

in that ques the word 'not' is missing...
cz if d word 'not' is nt present then...both (i) and (ii) would be d same...

and in ques no. 3 (b)

from the given facts in the question...

For producing 'A' ...one unit of 'B' is needed...

and in the question it is asked that at what price shall A transfer the product to 'B'...??
so when 'A' needs one unit of 'B'...thr is no logic that 'A' will supply it to 'B'..!!

so tht r d 2 mistakes in the ques paper which i hv found ..and hv answered it accordingly..

Prinz (-) (65 Points)
Replied 11 November 2011

In respect of 3rd Qn ,,,, i had to read 3 times just to understand what icai wanted! ABC system ... where are overheads ??

couldnt make head or tail of tht qn!!

i wrote..

for 1st instance, it is not required to introduce abc  and

for 2nd instance , it is required!! no basis .... jus tried ma luck!! matter of 8 marks!!!

CAKINGOFKINGS (STUDENT) (82 Points)
Replied 11 November 2011

1(i) was BEP I GUESS.....:( for wht volumes of mkt demand will manufacture recommended at all???dat wd b BEP no......

Prinz (-) (65 Points)
Replied 11 November 2011

In respect of 3rd Qn ,,,, i had to read 3 times just to understand what icai wanted! ABC system ... where are overheads ??

couldnt make head or tail of tht qn!!

i wrote..

for 1st instance, it is not required to introduce abc  and

for 2nd instance , it is required!! no basis .... jus tried ma luck!! matter of 8 marks!!!

another paper called "icai interprtation of english " should be added !! tht gives a 9th paper!!lol!!  omg

ritesh (CA) (106 Points)
Replied 11 November 2011

yes i too just realised the Q 3.b is wrongly framed... but i have answered it straight... lets see what happens....

cant see any mistake in Q1.1... anyways any suggestions on probable answer for q1.1??

Ravindranath G K (ARTICLE) (50 Points)
Replied 11 November 2011

Its really good that u upload Qpaper ... Thank You....CA Club

Prinz (-) (65 Points)
Replied 11 November 2011

In respect of 3rd Qn ,,,, i had to read 3 times just to understand what icai wanted! ABC system ... where are overheads ??

couldnt make head or tail of tht qn!!

i wrote..

for 1st instance, it is not required to introduce abc  and

for 2nd instance , it is required!! no basis .... jus tried ma luck!! matter of 8 marks!!!

another paper called "icai interprtation of english " should be added !! tht gives a 9th paper!!lol!!  omg

Prinz (-) (65 Points)
Replied 11 November 2011

oops! m sry.... have to chk werz this del button here!!

CA Akshay Bhandari (Chartered Accountant) (37 Points)
Replied 11 November 2011

Really Tough Paper.. Earlier OR was the saviour in Costing Exams - But In the New Scheme, OR cannot be depended upon for marks.

In todays paper - Standard Costing, Budgeting and Theory was the life saviour. Hope they give full marks in Std Costing and Budgeting and atleast half the marks in Theory. I have a feeling that I might just scrape through because of these topics.

view more »