Nobody notice that there is a big flaw on which GST is calculated?

mack (Thinking-to-start-business)   (154 Points)

19 December 2022  

Normally how GST is calculated :-

Persona ‘A’ (supplier) sell in 118/- to Person ‘B’ (intermediator/trader) who further add his margin of rupees 32/- this margin includes output GST and sell in (118+32) 150/- to final consumer. Now person ‘B’ will calculate GST @ 18% on 150/- that will come 27/- so Person ‘B’ will only pay Rs 9/- and the reaming 18/- is already paid by person ‘A’ and will show as Input tax credit against person ‘B’ GSTIN ?

 

But during all this process the % of GST was calculated by Person ‘B’ on the figure on which GST was already added by previous party ‘Person A’.

 

So with above situation government is getting 18% GST on 150/- price instead of price before GST

 

Person ‘A’ 100/-   [before GST is 100 and after GST is 118]

Person ‘B’   26.24/-   [this 26.24 is margin of person ‘B’ before output GST] so 32 include output GST

 

Total of Before GST from person ‘A’ + Person ‘B’

  100+26.24= 126.24/-

 

18% of 126.24 is = 22.7 this means that ‘Person B’ should give 22.7-18 = 4.7 as output tax rather than 9 rupees.

 

I hope you understand my question.