Considering the current Job market's position, it's hard for a person to get the job if he took more than one attempt to clear CA. Should Civil examination wil be a good option.
Considering the current Job market's position, it's hard for a person to get the job if he took more than one attempt to clear CA. Should Civil examination wil be a good option.
Rahul Sharma
(Be Always Positive)
(1603 Points)
Replied 11 February 2013
Rahul Sharma
(Be Always Positive)
(1603 Points)
Replied 11 February 2013
civil services is definitely better option but always remember there are few seats vary from 500 to 1000. students from iits, aiims & other good colleges from india preparing for it so more competition here compare to ca
PrinceAnil
(ca)
(51 Points)
Replied 11 February 2013
same opinion boss best option is civil wen comared to ca
Ganeshbabu K
(Audit and Tax Advisory)
(48559 Points)
Replied 12 February 2013
OBVIOUSLY CIVILS IS BETTER THAN CA-THERE IS NO DOUBT IN THAT
BUT CIVILS AFTER CA IS VERY MUCH BETTER...
BUT..ITS ALL DEPENDS ON PASSION OF STUDENTS
WHICH CAREER HE LOVES HE WILL GO AHEAD IN THAT PATH...
IN THESE DAYS STUDENTS APPEARING CIVIL EXAMS ALSO GROWING....
TINKU KUMAR GUPTA
(CA FINAL/CMA FINALSTUDENT)
(124 Points)
Replied 12 February 2013
Dear All,
I am also more interested in Civil Service exam but i am in ca and cma final and i planned to do prepare for these exam but when i will be completed ca and cma final at that time my age will come to 28 years and as per civil service rules that maximum 4 attempts are available for a general catagory candidate and at that time only i can give 2 attempts because my age will be at that time 28 years but one thing that i want to share amoung all of you that i am a very avg student and studied from a hindi medium school but i have passed my professional courses in first attempt and pls tell me what shoud i do.
shoud i prepare for civil service exam at this moment or prepare after the professional courses at the age of 28 years assuming if i passed all these professional course in first attempt but one thing i want to tell you all that i am so much interested for civil service exam and i can do very hard work for that but can a avg student pass civil service exam in english language done schooling from hindi language.
should i prepare for it right now or completing after these professional courses.
I need your valuable opinion pls reply me as early as possible and a further query that is central govt in the opinion to increase the age limit and maximum attempt for civil service exam for general catagory candidate
Thank You so much you all
Pawan Verma
(Assistant manager finance)
(186 Points)
Replied 13 February 2013
| Originally posted by : TINKU KUMAR GUPTA | ||
 |
Dear All, I am also more interested in Civil Service exam but i am in ca and cma final and i planned to do prepare for these exam but when i will be completed ca and cma final at that time my age will come to 28 years and as per civil service rules that maximum 4 attempts are available for a general catagory candidate and at that time only i can give 2 attempts because my age will be at that time 28 years but one thing that i want to share amoung all of you that i am a very avg student and studied from a hindi medium school but i have passed my professional courses in first attempt and pls tell me what shoud i do. shoud i prepare for civil service exam at this moment or prepare after the professional courses at the age of 28 years assuming if i passed all these professional course in first attempt but one thing i want to tell you all that i am so much interested for civil service exam and i can do very hard work for that but can a avg student pass civil service exam in english language done schooling from hindi language. should i prepare for it right now or completing after these professional courses. I need your valuable opinion pls reply me as early as possible and a further query that is central govt in the opinion to increase the age limit and maximum attempt for civil service exam for general catagory candidate Thank You so much you all |
 |
Dear Tinku
Im also a Civil service aspirant. But day by day it is moving out from reality.
Civil services is a way tougher exam as compared to CA. The primary reasons being the competetion and vastness of the subjects.
A General category candidate wanting to become an IAS officer should literally get in Top 100 out of 5 Lac aspirants. One can imagine the odds out there.
Iam not trying to discourage you but lets consider the Positives and Negatives of it.
Negatives:
1) Highly competitive (Prelims : 10000 out of 500000(2%)
(Mains : 800 out of 10000 (8%)
(Overall: 0.16% )
2) Do or Die. You dont have a recourse. I have seen plenty of people sitting in Delhi years and years and not able to crack it. In that case, the entire amount of time spent tends to be a waste.
3) Uncertainty of the Questioning pattern in the Mains .. Every year there's a change.
Positives:
1) While 5 lac is an absolute figure, The number of people who diligently prepare for the exam and write are less.
2) Once you are through with prelims, you need to be approximately 8 out of the 100 particpants writing the mains. Being in CA profession we are used to that pass percentage.
3) In Mains optionals - Commerce and Accountancy paper tends to be a plain vanilla for CA's. Hence we need to work only on the other optional.
CAclubindia
