Confusion of Place of Supply

"Good morning everyone, I hope you all are doing well."

Scene 1 Ek UP ka Registred Person (A) hai , Usne Haryana ke Registred Person se taxable Goods Purchases Kiya aur Incoterm ( Ex Work) par, Haryana ke supplier ne IGST apply Kiya,

Secne 2  Ab UP ke Above Person (A) ne Same Place Par (Haryana) hi Bina Goods ko Movment kiye 2nd UP ke Registerd Person (B) ko Sale Kar Diya Aur Incoterm bhi same rahi (EX WORKS).

Q.1 Ab E way Bill Generate karne Ki Liabilitiy kiski hai? Supplier or Buyer?

Q. 2 Jab Person (A) Person (B) ko Invoice Dega to Kaunsa GST Head  Apply karega? IGST or CGST SGST 

Scene 3 Person(B) ne wahi goods Haryan ke same place se hi apne Buyer joki Punjab me regiterd person hai uske liye movment kara diya, ab ye person(B) Bill to Ship to ki Tanjection ko select karke eway bill generate karega aur IGST Charge Karega, 

Confusion : Secne 2 ki Trenjection me hai , ki Person(A) Person(B) se IGS, ya CGST SGST lega? Aur Uske Buer Person(B) ko koi ITC ka Risk To Nahi?

"I hope you all can understand my concern and help me find a way out."

Thnaks

Replies (3)
Quick Summary
This discussion clarifies confusion around the place of supply for GST, particularly concerning e-way bill generation and applicable GST heads. It breaks down three scenarios involving inter-state purchases, intra-state sales without goods movement, and subsequent inter-state sales. The analysis explains who is liable for e-way bills and whether IGST or CGST/SGST applies in each case, ensuring clarity on Input Tax Credit (ITC) risks.

Scenario Analysis Let's break down the scenarios and address your questions:

Scenario 1: Purchase from Haryana Supplier - *IGST Applicability*: Since the goods are being transported from Haryana to UP, IGST is applicable. -

 *E-way Bill Generation*: The supplier (Haryana registered person) is responsible for generating the e-way bill, as the movement of goods is initiated by the supplier.

Scenario 2: Sale from UP Person (A) to UP Person (B) without Movement -

*GST Applicability*: Since both parties are registered in UP and the goods are not moving, this is an intra-state supply.

Therefore, CGST and SGST would be applicable. - 

*E-way Bill Generation*: In this case, since there is no movement of goods, an e-way bill is not required. Scenario 3: Sale from UP Person (B) to Punjab Buyer 

- *GST Applicability*: Since the goods are being transported from UP to Punjab, IGST is applicable. - 

*E-way Bill Generation*: Person (B) would need to generate an e-way bill for the movement of goods to Punjab.

 They would select the "Bill To - Ship To" transaction type and charge IGST. Key Takeaways -

*Scenario 2 GST Head*: Person (A) would charge CGST and SGST to Person (B), as it's an intra-state supply. - 

*ITC Risk for Person (B)*: Person (B) would be eligible for ITC on the CGST and SGST charged by Person (A), provided they have a valid invoice and have paid the GST amount.

 By understanding the GST implications and e-way bill requirements for each scenario, you can ensure compliance with GST regulations and avoid any potential issues.

Scenario Analysis Let's break down the scenarios and address your questions:

Scenario 1: Purchase from Haryana Supplier - *IGST Applicability*: Since the goods are being transported from Haryana to UP, IGST is applicable. -

 *E-way Bill Generation*: The supplier (Haryana registered person) is responsible for generating the e-way bill, as the movement of goods is initiated by the supplier.

Scenario 2: Sale from UP Person (A) to UP Person (B) without Movement -

*GST Applicability*: Since both parties are registered in UP and the goods are not moving, this is an intra-state supply.

Therefore, CGST and SGST would be applicable. - 

*E-way Bill Generation*: In this case, since there is no movement of goods, an e-way bill is not required. Scenario 3: Sale from UP Person (B) to Punjab Buyer 

- *GST Applicability*: Since the goods are being transported from UP to Punjab, IGST is applicable. - 

*E-way Bill Generation*: Person (B) would need to generate an e-way bill for the movement of goods to Punjab.

 They would select the "Bill To - Ship To" transaction type and charge IGST. Key Takeaways -

*Scenario 2 GST Head*: Person (A) would charge CGST and SGST to Person (B), as it's an intra-state supply. - 

*ITC Risk for Person (B)*: Person (B) would be eligible for ITC on the CGST and SGST charged by Person (A), provided they have a valid invoice and have paid the GST amount.

 By understanding the GST implications and e-way bill requirements for each scenario, you can ensure compliance with GST regulations and avoid any potential issues.

Scene 2: A should charge Haryana CGST and Haryana SGST—not IGST—on the sale to B. Under the IGST Act, the place of supply for goods involving no movement is where the goods are located when delivered to the recipient. The goods are in Haryana, so the supply is intra-State, even though A and B are registered in Uttar Pradesh. A’s purchase from the Haryana supplier is also generally a Haryana intra-State supply on these facts; the “Ex Works” term alone does not make it inter-State. The supplier’s IGST invoice therefore needs review and correction.

  • E-way bill: For a supply involving movement, the registered person causing the movement—supplier or recipient—may generate it. In Scene 2 there is no movement, so an e-way bill is generally not required merely for that sale. Any later movement must be assessed on its own facts, including the applicable distance and exemptions.
  • Scene 3: If B arranges movement from Haryana to Punjab, the goods’ movement is from Haryana to Punjab; B’s supply to the Punjab buyer is generally inter-State and attracts IGST. A bill-to/ship-to structure may be relevant if the statutory conditions are met, but the invoice and e-way bill must reflect the actual parties, movement and delivery instructions.
  • B’s ITC risk: B should not claim IGST charged by A on a Haryana-to-Haryana supply. A should issue a corrected tax invoice and account for Haryana CGST/SGST; B’s eligibility to claim that credit depends on the applicable registration, invoice and ITC conditions. The exact e-way-bill responsibility and bill-to/ship-to documentation depend on who arranges each movement and the contractual delivery terms.

Getting the place of supply and invoice tax head right at each resale is essential to the GST reconciliation and e-way-bill workflow. Manual checks across invoices, delivery terms and transport records are difficult; automation reduces repetitive work while keeping professional judgment in control. At Jir AI, our 2,000+ AI agents and 650+ integrations streamline GST, ITR, TDS, TCS and other compliance workflows, helping reduce manual workload by up to 70%. WhatsApp us to explore a workflow for your practice: https://wa.me/message/3HVOZ7HIY4ESC1

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register  

Company
ARTICLESHIP 18 November 2026
Articled Assistant

A.Singhi & Co

Kolkata

CA Inter

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 14 November 2026
Article Assistant

Jitendra Agarwal & Associates

Bengaluru

CA Inter

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 07 November 2026
Article Assisstant

DPV & Associates

Chennai

CA Inter

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 28 October 2026
Article assistants

Shyam S Gupta and Company

New Delhi

CA Inter

View Details
Company
21 November 2026
Asst. Manager / Deputy Manager

Aco Perfumes & Cosmetic Pvt Ltd

Mumbai

CA

View Details
Company
30 October 2026
Asst Manager Accounts

Goodwin Pumps India Pvt Ltd

Chengalpattu

CA Inter

View Details
Company
20 November 2026
Article

S & N CO

Mumbai

CA Inter

View Details
Company
10 November 2026
Direct Tax Manager

CAAQ CONSULTANCY PVT LTD

New Delhi

CA Final

View Details