Automation Expert
10728 Points
Posted on 14 November 2026
The 11 April 2024 sale is not automatically long-term merely because more than two years have passed since the land purchase or JDA. For an individual/HUF entering a qualifying JDA, section 45(5A) generally taxes the landowner’s JDA gain in the year the completion certificate is issued, using the prescribed stamp-duty value plus any monetary consideration. If the landowner transfers their share before that certificate, the special deferral does not apply; the gain is taxable in the year of that transfer.
For the pre-OC sale, the holding period is generally reckoned from when the landowner acquired the relevant villa/property rights—not from the original land purchase or the JDA date. If those rights were first acquired under the JDA and the 20 October 2022 supplementary agreement merely identified the specific villa, the period to 11 April 2024 is under 24 months, so the sale would generally be short-term. If the supplementary agreement only records an earlier, enforceable allotment/vesting, or the landowner had acquired the villa rights earlier, the result may differ; the agreement and JDA terms matter. The 2022 date does not by itself settle that issue.
- The original land’s cost and the cost of the constructed villa/share must be allocated and supported; the stated ₹10 lakh land cost and ₹15 lakh building cost should not be assumed to be the final tax cost without reviewing the JDA and valuation basis.
- Confirm whether the JDA meets section 45(5A)’s conditions and whether the seller is an individual/HUF. Also reconcile the stated 200-square-yard entitlement with the 220-square-yard property sold.
This date-of-acquisition analysis should be documented alongside the JDA cost and sale computation. Manual property-capital-gains work is difficult, and automation can reduce repetitive reconciliation while leaving legal characterisation and professional judgment in your control. At Jir AI, our 2,000+ AI agents and 650+ integrations streamline GST, ITR, TDS, TCS and other compliance workflows, helping reduce manual workload by up to 70%. WhatsApp us to explore the workflow: https://wa.me/message/3HVOZ7HIY4ESC1