SEO Sai Gr. Hosp.
40 Points
Posted on 08 September 2016
"Now my main question is Whether any chance of IT officer will say that......"
Bound to arise, whichever way you put. Its their duty. You have to prepare for your protection, that too under law.
The JDA chapter is very debatable. You can get contraversial judgements over same point.
In your case land owner cannot be a businessman based on following:
Points to be considered while determining whether the activity is trading or investment
Original intention of the party
Magnitude of the transactions of purchase
Nature of the property
Length of its ownership and holding
The conduct and subsequent dealings of the assessee in respect of the property
& most important: Frequency and multiplicity of transactions.
Case law:
CIT v Shashi Kumar Agarwal (2003) 131 Taxman 823 (All)
Profit on sale of land after plotting it out to secure better price cannot be taxed as profits from an adventure in the nature of trade. It shall be taxed under the head ‘ Capital gain’.
Many more judgements available if you seriously search: Few best suitable for your study are:
(2003) 176 TAXATION 276 (BOM)
(2014) TAXCORP(LJ) 2700 (ITAT-HYDERABAD)