Subscribe to CCI PRO and support your CAclubindia community. Click Here!
caclubindia logo
  • News
    Income Tax GST Students Corporate Law Audit More ...
  • Articles
    Income Tax Students GST Corporate Law Service Tax More ...
  • Forum
    Income Tax Students GST Corporate Law Accounts More ...
  • Experts
    Income Tax Students GST Service Tax Accounts More ...
  • Notices
    Customs Income Tax GST Corporate Law Shares and Stock More ...
  • Files
    Income Tax Students GST Corporate Law Accounts More ...
  • Judiciary
    Income Tax LAW GST Corporate Law Service Tax More ...
  • Learning
  • Books
  • Jobs
CCI Pro Sign In 
Site
Course
Site
Course

Excel Mastery Program

CA Rishabh Pugalia   INR 1999

Certification Course on Chat GPT and AI Tools for Professionals

CA Deepak Gupta   INR 399

Live Session on JDA Transactions in Real Estate

CA Vishal G Poddar   INR 499

Certification Course on Practical Filing of Income Tax Returns

CA Pratibha Goyal   INR 799
Close
  • Popular Courses
  • LIVE
  • GST
  • Tally
  • Excel
  • MsOffice
  • Income Tax
  • Accounting
  • CA
  • CS
  • EPF Live Course
  • More classes
  • Courses :
  • Live
  • EPF Live Course
  • View All
  1. Home
  2. Forum
  3. Income Tax

CA's better decision maker as compared to MBA's

Guneet Kaur

Guneet Kaur (Asst Manager) (326 Points)

13 April 2010  

 

CA’s better decision maker as compared to MBA’s

Chartered accountants, the nuts-and-bolts professionals in the world of finance, are scoring brownie points over suave MBA finance graduates as India Inc gets increasingly risk-averse in a post-slowdown environment.

 

Companies are focusing more on risk-compliance than pursuing ambitious targets as they recover from an 18-month economic downturn, paving the way for recruitment of more CAs, perceived to have core competence in financial matters.

 

Thus, CA’s are currently being accepted as business leaders who could take up roles beyond auditing and financial management. While MBA’s are being hired for purely sales, marketing or international trade functions, CA’s are increasingly being looked upon as decision-makers.

 

CA’s have an edge over MBA 

 

§  Chartered Accountants are superior to MBAs. They are already groomed for three years during articleship in training with auditors and can start working from day one

 

§  Corporate India getting cautious with salaries, CA’s are gaining a natural edge. If companies are unable to afford an MBA from a top B-School, they would rather hire a top CA & look for a management graduate from lower-rung B-schools.

 

 

 

Source >> www.forum4finance.com

 



Reply

Follow

Share

More
  •   Start a discussion
  •   Unanswered
  • Report Abuse

 8 Replies


(Guest)

 my dear in this practical world performance is count  weather ca mba or even i say ssc or hsc

 

so try to performance form ur first day of job

Online classes for CA CS CMA. Professional courses for GST, Tally, Others & Books
Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

CourseCart.in

CourseCart.in (Mentor at SHAYVIDZ Academy)   (3756 Points)
Replied 13 April 2010

work, experience & knowledge counts !! not the degree !!

 

I hv seen so many CAs who is not having knowledge of even Final Level... And on the other hand, there are so many CA Final Student who are having more knowledge & experience than Qualified CAs...

  


koolleo87

koolleo87 (1268 Points)
Replied 13 April 2010

'' To conclude; CAs will be CAs and MBAs will be MBAs. It is true that CAs value has increased a lot than it was 10 years back. But we still have a lot way to go. ''



WELL, THE VALUE OF EVEN PLUMBERS AND CARPENTERS HAS INCREASED FROM 10 YEARS BACK.... ITS PURELY DUE TO ECONOMIC GROWTH AND INFLATION. A RISING TIDE LIFTS EVERYONE UP. SO ITS NOT THE MAGIC OF THE CA COURSE.

.

.

ALSO, ANY SUCH NEWSPAPER ARTICLE SHOULD BE BASED ON FACTS AND FIGURES. THEY HAVENT GIVEN ANY FACTS AND FIGURES. ONLY THAT SOME BIG 4 FIRM IS PLANNING TO HIRE. WELL, IT IS A CA FIRM. SO IT IS BOUND TO HIRE CA'S ONLY. IF THE ARTICLES TALKS OF SUBSTITUTING MBA'S FOR CA'S SHOW A COMPANY WHICH IS ACTUALLY DOING SO RATHER THAN A CA FIRM ITSELF.

.

.



ALSO, LOOK MORE CLOSELY AND YOU WILL FIND THAT THE ARTICLE ACTUALLY GOES AGAINST COMMON SENSE.

1) Loyalty also tilts the balance in their favour.

I DONT KNOW WHAT BULL SHIT IT MEANS. BUT AS I UNDERSTAND, IT MEANS THAT A CA WHO IS GETTING BETTER PROSPECTS SOMEWHERE WILL NOT SHIFT DUE TO THE LOYALTY FACTOR BUT AN MBA WILL DO SO. WHICH COMPELS ME TO THINK, IS THE ARTICLE PRAISING CA'S OR SAYING WE ARE DUMB ASSES ???

2) If a company is unable to afford an MBA from a top B-School, it would rather hire a top CA.

WELL, LOW QUALITY PRODUCTS ARE CHEAPER THAN HIGH QUALITY PRODUCTS. NO DOUBT ABOUT IT...

.

.

.

FINALLY, I WONDER IF ITS A PART OF THE IMAGE BUILDING EXERECISE BY THE ICAI. SOUNDS FAR FETCHED BUT STILL, THERE IS A REMOTE POSSIBILITY. JOSE HAS SAID ENOUGH ABOUT SKILLS OF ICAI. WELL, I WOULD NOT ELABORATE ON IT. THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THE SALARIES OF MBA'S AND CA'S SAY IT ALL.

.

.

@ Everyone. FOR THOSE WHO STILL THINK THAT THIS ARTICLE IS SOMETHING GREAT AND WHO WILL COMMENT THAT '' CA IS THE BEST '' , '' MBA'S ARE NOTHING '' AND BLAH BLAH BLAH, I HAVE ONLY ONE THING TO SAY -- GROW UP....


SUDHIR & PRADEEP JI

SUDHIR & PRADEEP JI (CA FINAL+LLB + DISA) (2299 Points)
Replied 14 April 2010

only depend upon the experience of the person.and    how its six sense working ok


Max Payne

Max Payne (employed) (2574 Points)
Replied 14 April 2010

I feel this article is uninformed and derogatory to Chartered accountants.

Whats the comparison that MBAs are suave and we are nuts and bolts? Its the suave CAs that land the good jobs. 

 

While the heading of the article points in one direction, the entire text reads like an american executive saying

"China is the new India. Ten heads for the price of one!"

According to this article, hiring a CA has been reduced to a cost cutting process.

 

Contradicting the heading of this article, CAs are actually proven DUMB decision makers. Loyalty my foot.

And like Adarsh has said, there is no conclusive proof of anything. Dont generalise this kind of statement.

 

And next time pls dont cut copy paste from the Economic times


Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

Hardik Dave

Hardik Dave (IPCC and CS Professional(FINAL) Student)   (15533 Points)
Replied 14 April 2010

Chak de CA

CA Devanshi Gandhi (Ajani)

CA Devanshi Gandhi (Ajani) (FCA DISA Mcom CIFRS & LLB)   (9060 Points)
Replied 14 April 2010

Degree is must to have a job in initial stage only but ur knowledge will decide where ur future will be.......


CA CS CIMA Prakash Somani

CA CS CIMA Prakash Somani (Landmark Group) (23507 Points)
Replied 14 April 2010

Feel proud to be CA :) We are because of CA and CA is because of us :) So both of we should proud on each one :)



Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register  

Join CCI Pro

Recent Topics


  • Recent HSN Changes - B2B and B2C
  • New ITR FORMS 1 AND 4
  • Changes in Form 15G and 15H, if any?
  • Is Exam / Certification fee of directors allowed a
  • Converting a Partner to Nominal Partner – Ze
  • GST on labour charges in respect of manufacturing
  • AIS not able to access
  • GST Input Related Query for Cab Services
  • Sale of Assets of Partnership firm
  • Suggest a fasttrack class for CA Inter costing for

More recent discussions | Post

Related Threads


Loading

Popular Discussion


    Loading please wait

view more »


Start a New Discussion
CCI Pro

Trending Online Classes

  • Live Course on EPF & ESI Act - Mastercourse(With Govt Certificate)

    Mr.Balamurugan Ranganathan
    Mr.Balamurugan Ranganathan
    Enroll Now
    16 June 2025
  • Guide to UAE Corporate Tax Return filing (3rd Live Batch)

    CA Mohd Asim
    CA Mohd Asim
    Enroll Now
    14 June 2025
  • Professional ITR Preparer Course

    Saniya Mushrif
    Saniya Mushrif
    Enroll Now
    31 May 2025
view all classess


Subscribe to the latest topics :

Search Forum:

Forum Home
Popular Threads
Recent Posts
Unreplied Threads
Post New Topic
Settings



  • Articles
  • Forum
  • Jobs
  • Judiciary
  • Settings
  • News
  • Experts
  • Share Files
  • Notification
  • Certification Courses
  • Categories
  • Feed
  • Bookmarks
  • Top Members
  • CCI Rewards
  • Live Classes
  • Books
  • CCI Learning
  • Group
  • CCI Pro
Member Strength 4184094 and growing..
Find Us On

  • About
  • We are Hiring
  • Media Coverage
  • Advertise
  • Terms of Service
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
© 2025 CAclubindia.com. India's largest network for Finance Professionals
Share
 Facebook
 Twitter
 Linkedin
 Reddit
 Email
 Whatsapp
 Gmail
 Pocket
 Print
 Pinterest
 PDF
 Translate
Whatsapp Groups
GST
Income Tax
CA Final
CA Inter
CAclubindia
Login at CAclubindia

cciCAclubindia

India's largest network for
finance professionals



login
Forgot Password ?

Alternatively, you can log in using:

Login with Facebook
Login with Google

Don't have an account? Register Now

click here to register