Vinay Raja (student-IPCC) 29 November 2010
RSP Limited allotted 500 fully paid-up shares of Rs. 100 each to Z, a minor, in response to his application without
knowing that he was a minor and entered his name in the Register of members. Later on, the company came to know
of this fact. The company cancelled the allotment and struck-off his name from the Register of members and also
forfeited his entire share money. He filed a suit against the action of the company. Decide whether Z would be given
any relief by the court under the provisions of the Companies Act, 1956.
In simple Allotment was made for a minor for fully paidup shares in primary market.
In solution set it is given that it is valid since the allotment was made to minor for fully paidup shares!!
But as far as I know, it was held by NCLT in Nandita Jain Vs Bennet Coleman&Co. Ltd. that
A minor can become a member only if:
1) company is a limited company
2)Shares are fully paid
3)Application of transfer(means secondary market) is made on behalf of minor by lawful guardian.
I strongly remeber that minor cannot be alloted shares in primary market as he is not competent to contractual relationship(as per Contract Act)
Please clarify me on this, whether allotement can be made, did any provision relating to this change??
CAclubindia Online Learning offers a wide variety of online classes and video lectures for various professional courses such as CA, CS, CMA, CISA as well as various certification courses on GST, Transfer Pricing, International Taxation, Excel, Tally, FM, Ind AS and more. know more
Santhosh Poojary (SIEMPRE AHÍ PARA TI) 29 November 2010
i Agree that that minor cannot be alloted shares in primary market as he is not competent to contractual relationship as per Indian Contract Act 1872.
Harie (student) 29 November 2010
As per Diwan Singh Vs Minerva Films Ltd., A minor can become a member of a company by acquiring shares subject to the following conditions
- should be by way of transfer
- The shares are fully paid up
- No further liability is attached to the shares
Hence a minor can become a member only by way of secondary market and not by primary market.