CA Final
156 Points
Joined June 2008
Q5 a) Maximum Price Y can trasfer..there are two views
View 1 = 640 - 64 = 576 ( assuming 64 is the cost of 2 hours...[Variable cost of Rs 40 per hour is for the production of Wheels...It cant be asumed that same cost will be incurred for modification of Gears)
View 2 = 640 - 64 - 80 = 496 (assuming 2 hrs as opportunity cost .. which could have been utilized for manufacturing of Wheels)
Anyway, in both the views the the remaining answer to question will not change.
ii) Minimum Transfer price X will demand if transfers 5000 qty to Y....
Situation a = 620.80 per gear
Situation b = 496 per gear
Situation c = 616 gear
iii) So in situation b Management can step in and compel X to transfer 5000 gears to Y
I think lot of people will disagree with answer iii.
But guys in situation a & situation b ... Y division can import gears @ 640. So company will do better in importing & management cant compel ... as overall company's profit will reduce.
so management can compel only in situation 'b'