Vat of previous year

Mahavir Jain (Proprietor) (28 Points)

04 February 2013  

 

Sir my query is
One of my client at the time of  finalization of Tax Audit of AY. 2009-10 has shown a amount of rs. 230000/- receivable from Sales tax department as excess payment to department but when VAT audit of same was conducted this figure was brought down to rs. 10300/-  due to in admissibility of certain tax paid but not eligible category .
Tax Audit is signed on 23.09.09 & VAt audit was signed on 20.01.2010, i.e. during FY 2010-11.
My question is what effect is to be given in FY 2010-11 as we cannot go back to AY 2009-10.
Whether writing down Rs. 219700/- in P&L of AY  2010-11 is justified, if yes please provide us with any such case law.
Please reply me on mahavir @ camahavir.com