Menu
Scored 500 marks in ca finals and yet failed
Bt a per rule...he can avail exemption in 2 subject only..
No Subject is irrelevant.
He will study ISCA and he'll pass.
I think what is the use of studing this type of paper***********
ISCA? What it really gives knowledge about ? This is a very interesting case of following rules & laws at the cost of justice.
I have observed in my life several cases where prudence ( not the accountant's prudence here ), intelligence logics & brain is not used. AND JUST A RULE IS FOLLOWED AT THE COST OF JUSTICE.
RULES ARE MADE FOR THE ULTIMATE OBJECTIVE OF JUSTICE.
500 marks in final ca is unimaginable success.
His bad luck for this time and his gud luck is that he can prepare this 3 mnths only isca subject nd can cmplt 4 sure...icai has became so tough in letting students cmplt the course
I think revaluation is better
-
Samundar Mein Fanaa Hona Toh Kismat Ka Khel Hai!
Joh Marta Hein Kinaroon Par Mujhe Dukh Unpe Aata Hai...
This is really bad luck..... This had happened to me, because of 8 marks in ISCA only, I had lost second group three years before.... It is really unfortunate to the students.... So be prepared for the below PROVERB.
" DO YOUR BEST & BE READY FOR THE WORST"
Apply for rechecking
I am also facing same problem. Only Because of ISCA I was not become C.A.
Good luck for next attempt
Institute must change its rule.he must be allowed atleast to claim exemption in all the three papers of second group
please all request icai to change its exemption rule
I don't thing it is unfare to Sambhav as he failed to one subject. I would like to put my own experience
I failed 2nd group because of aggregate as I could not get 50% only got 49% though I was passed in every subject with minimun marks of 48 & maximum with 50.
I would like to quote on song " how many road u must cross before u could called as a MAN" so don't feel bad Shambhav it is a part of a life of ca student. A good road is waiting for you
Rules r rules
N dnt blame policies... its tough..bt still gotta live by it.
Recent Topics :
- How to find a good CA
- Rcm on rent paid
- Clarify on GST Application
- Residential status for overseas students visitin
- Capital Gains Tax
- LTCG 112A and business loss
- FAST-DS 2026 applicability: foreign employee share
- NRI Property Sale in India: TDS Rates and Key Comp
- Clarification on September 2026 PF Calculation for
- DRC-03 interest paid under CGST/SGST instead of IG
Related Topics :
CAclubindia
