Manish valecha vs dinesh madan for self study

Final 3777 views 10 replies

spendinsumtym

student

180 Points Joined December 2010

Hi everyone, I am in CA FINAL..... As per recommendations of my senior I started studying ISCA from Study material and now I am facing huge problem in understanding and learing the concepts...The language in module is very complex and presentation very boring... I am not able to retain it.....

Please suggest which book should I buy now- Dinesh Madan or Manish Valecha???

I dont want to study from more than 1 book, Please suggest which one is more exam oriented, student friendly and have better for understanding........

Please help me out .......

Replies (10)

Rohit Kapoor

CA Final

543 Points Joined May 2011

M valecha is better.

spendinsumtym

student

180 Points Joined December 2010

Does Manish Valecha's book updated for changes in ISCA applicable for Nov 2012?

CA PuRvI M!$rA

2260 Points Joined November 2009

dinesh madan is better.......

rahul

Chartered Accountant

5572 Points Joined June 2010

Originally posted by : spendinsumtym
	Does Manish Valecha's book updated for changes in ISCA applicable for Nov 2012?

Manish Valechha is much better. January 2012 changes are very well explained in valechha only as compare to others (in dinesh madan... explanations given are not proper, I cant understand why people recommend dinesh madan). See both the books and decide youself. July 2012 edition of this book is fully updated for Nov 2012. July 2012 edn is available at cabooksonline.com. Visit the following link.

https://www.cabooksonline.com/viewlatest.php?id=1824

Jayant

CA CS Final

171 Points Joined August 2011

Originally posted by : Rohit Kapoor
	M valecha is better.

spendinsumtym

student

180 Points Joined December 2010

I think u r right rahul, one of my fren told me thar updates/changes in Dinesh Madan are very haphazard...not properly incorporated......

spendinsumtym

student

180 Points Joined December 2010

Over the years everyone refering to Dinesh Madan but now there is this change in scenario more and more people are going for Mansih Valecha I guess this change is for good.......

rahul

Chartered Accountant

5572 Points Joined June 2010

Originally posted by : spendinsumtym
	Over the years everyone refering to Dinesh Madan but now there is this change in scenario more and more people are going for Mansih Valecha I guess this change is for good.......

this is becouse, if you read one chapter from manish valecha isca textbook, you wont refer anything else. try it youeself.

all the best.