Updated Online video classes available for CA,CS,CMA for May20 and Nov20 batch. Call: 1800-3000-0505

Long term cg calculation with grand fathering - which approach is right?

incometaxquery (Software Engineer)     20 July 2019

Software Engineer 
 52 points

| My Other Post

Hi All

Can you please look at the following case and let me know how is the tax to be calculated and how it is to be entered in ITR and in which section?

Stock Purchase Cost FMV on 31st 2018 Sale Price Gain
A 43000 28000 7000 -35000
B 63000 88000 93000 +5000
Calculations 106000 116000 100000  

So, if you see above, if I do calculations on stock by stock, my gain is -35000+5000 = -30000 (APPROACH 1)

However, if I have to add up everything and then do the calculations, then my gain is 100000-116000 = -16000 (APPROACH 2)

Which of the two approaches is correct?

Then how do you enter in ITR, particularly if the right answer is -30000? Which section in CG ? I could not find a way to enter multiple rows to follow Approach 1 in ITR.




Dhirajlal Rambhia (KVO Merau Kutchh)     21 July 2019

Dhirajlal Rambhia
KVO Merau Kutchh 
 9127 likes  92666 points

View Profile | My Other Post

1. For Stock no. A..... Loss is 36,000/- and not 35K

2. First approach is right, as per law.

3. Fill the data scriptt-wise in schedule 112A, it will take care.

1 Like

Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register  

Popular Discussion

view more »